
Australian rockers, Karnivool, often receive comparisons to Tool. That’s harder to justify over the years as they’ve developed their own sound, but they take after the LA legends in one respect: the long gaps between albums. In Verses is their first LP since 2013’s Asymmetry sailed to number one in the Australian charts. It’s only the fourth album of a career that started in 1998. No wonder they’re a cult band outside their native country.
You can always expect a record like this to begin with celestial guitar effects that imitate synthesisers, just as you should expect a chugging bassline to contrast it. But Karnivool are not in the game of doing the expected in ‘Ghost’. Listen how the guitars create a drag effect from the gravity of the main beat. Ian Kenny’s voice is unchanged since 2013’s last outing, which is great news for fans of this band. The snippets of Maynard James Keenan in his vocal lines are still there, but Kenny has his own command when he pushes for the higher octaves. Drummer, Steve Judd, reaches for the rim clicks when the dynamics explore calmer pastures, but you know a terrific jolt of down-tuned chords will bring them back up again. The breakdown at the end is good enough to extend for another twenty seconds.
Those that doubt the original aspects of this cult band should listen to the strange rock & roll guitar slides transplanted on top of the growling bass and drum groove of ‘Drone’. How do they make something as anachronistic as this work so well? The answer: they let Ian Kenny take control with his melodic vocal lines and threaten a slurry of distortion when the drums come to life. At a slimmed down five minutes in length, it reminds us that Karnivool know how to control their impulses towards longer song structures. Yet ‘Aozora’ does the opposite and operates in that vibrant middle lane that demarcates the boundaries between rock and metal. It saunters for over six minutes, teasing riffs that never materialise and subsisting on a clean drum beat that could grace any Led Zeppelin album. A catchy chorus saves it from the fate of mediocrity as Kenny elevates his head voice with a wonderful vibrato technique.
One thing this band have always possessed in abundance is a dreamy sense of melody. ‘Animation’ employs guitars like harps in the intro before it finds its rhythm (it might even be a harp). Its tone is darker and less interested in the light. The eruption of fuzz in the chorus offers a release from the tension. Yes, it’s predictable but it gives you what you need. Prog lovers can satisfy themselves analysing the sporadic guitar effects that permeate through the verses like distant sparklers in the hands of children. Eight minutes of brave smiles and concealing a secret sorrow is the default mood of ‘Conversations’. The atmosphere is redolent of The Cure in the Bloodflowers era. Jon Stockman is wise to use his bass as the headlight with so much room in the channels. By contrast, Drew Goddard and Mark Hosking are content to take the U2 approach in the verses and the droning Bush option in the chorus. Is this acceptable after thirteen years? It hardly matters with Ian Kenny’s anxiety drawing you closer to his fragile voice. A wonderful fade out of “Keep digging / Keep digging now,” leaves you wondering what existential crisis weighs him down so much.
Scottish guitar god, Guthrie Govan, is the guest of honour in ‘Reanimation’, which spends most of its time in a delta blues Depeche Mode conundrum. The vocal harmonies are ghostly in their effect before Ian Kenny takes the microphone. “It’s always gonna be this way / I face oblivion / I couldn’t have it any other way,” croons the frontman. It makes you wonder if Silverchair might’ve ended up here if they returned in 2026 under the vision of rock supremo, Daniel Johns. Few bands can write a chorus as engaging and as honest as this with buzzing guitar amps. And their decision to remaster their standalone 2021 single, ‘All It Takes’, for this LP is the right call. This is the song that pulsates with a metallic groove and a sludgy bassline that could strip the hairs off your arms. Observe how the rolling chord shapes force their way into a circular riff as Kenny delivers his best lyric: “I don’t wanna prey on your honesty / But I can’t excuse your naivety.” It’s the one track here that can sit next to their 2007 classic, ‘Goliath’. Let’s hope the next Haken or Tesseract album can nail down something as poignant.
You wonder at track eight if they might turn a good record into an excellent one. ‘Remote Self-Control’ has the same punch as its predecessor song and thrives on choppy drop-tuned guitars and a shoulder-bopping bass for the boxing ring. Unfortunately, they squander this late momentum with two shiny ballads that showcase Ian Kenny’s stellar voice but do little on a musical level to excite the listener. A combined running time of fourteen minutes between ‘Opal’ and ‘Salva’ is unjustifiable when there’s a modicum of tension in both and only one recurring moment of astral Black Sabbath riffing to retain your attention.
It took them thirteen years to get here, and there’s little for Karnivool fans to dislike. But will this be their last album?
Kirk Houghton
Verdict


Release Date: 06/02/2026
Record Label: Cymatic Records
Standout tracks: Ghost, All It Takes, Remote Self-Control
Suggested Further Listening: Tesseract – Altered State (2013), Caligula’s Horse – Rise Radiant (2020), Black Orchid Empire – Tempus Veritas (2022)
