
French quintet, The Old Dead Tree, appeared to have closed the chapter on their career after releasing their 2019 EP, The End. Active between 1997 and 2007 and more in tune with progressive death metal, the band reformed in 2013 on the tenth anniversary of their debut album and tried once again in 2017 to get things moving. Finally, they have a new album of fourteen songs and close to an hour’s worth of new material. You ought to be excited until you realise that they’ve become a generic gothic metal band.
A synth like ‘Pinball Wizard’ by The Who introduces the striding guitars and drums in opening song, ‘Unpredictable’. Manuel Munoz shows great confidence at the microphone after so many years away as the band sketch the chorus early on and insert spaces where the crowd can “whoah-oh-oh” with waving arms. You can hear sliding intervals ring out in distortion underneath the sharp drum production. It’s surprising how innocuous the former sound despite moving away from the standard power chords. Musically, ‘Don’t Waste Your Time’ is like an ethereal version of Katatonia circa 2003, until they thicken the weight with faster riffing at 02:10 in place of a guitar solo. Idle threats to break out into something more sinister lie beneath the surface.
The atmosphere of Second Thoughts is consistent for being as frosty as it is melancholy. So, why are these songs so hard to remember after two listens? They have all the right ingredients – powerful vocals, distorted guitars, sharp drums, half-timing chorus movements – yet together they sound bland. Even the chugs and double-kick accents after the second chorus in ‘The Lightest Straw’ struggle to gather momentum as anything other than fleeting moments of aggression. Fortunately, they get into gear at track four and five in the double-attack of ‘Better Off Dead’ and ‘Without a Second Thought’. The former sees Munoz display an impressive Jeff Buckley voice of shivering falsetto notes at the end of each line. It goes straight into the latter with a chunky My Dying Bride riff and malevolent vocals. Now, you can appreciate the metallic finesse of the guitars as much as the rim clicks in the calmer middle eight.
The middle section of this album is the strongest. Let the solemn church bells in ‘Luke’ transport you to a post-plague society where no birds survive, and the land offers no crops. Listen how the band members use competing vocal harmonies to sing the lyrics in the opening verses. The Old Dead Tree are at their weakest when they go through the motions of being a rock band. By contrast, they show their true talent when focusing on atmospherics and complex vocal arrangements. This song offers a rare example of a memorable chorus on first listen. Likewise, the axemen display more imagination in their rhythms for ‘Story of My Life’ as the thudding bass lays down the main beat. A rare change of tempo to a new sequence of drums and keyboard strings retains your attention when you think you’ve figured out the structure. This is another number with a triumphant chorus delivery, unlike the earlier tracks.
But fourteen verse-chorus songs spread over fifty-seven minutes is excessive, like the last record by Swallow the Sun. Most of them come in under four minutes, some of which fall into the inevitable filler category. ‘I Wish I Could’ resembles an attempt at punk rock with a Bauhaus twist until they pull back in the chorus with a radio friendly uplift. “I wish I could travel back in time when everything was fine,” laments Munoz. ‘Fresh Start’ is too reliant on the vocal melodies and charismatic presence of their singer, but gothic metal fans will recognise the unimaginative guitar work. Your attention begins to wander by track eleven (‘Solastalgia’). Do we need a piano rumination at this point of the album? The call-and-response vocals in the first verse are like Queen at their most experimental. This would’ve been more effective as track number three on the album.
It’s even more frustrating how The Old Dead Tree remind us of their former glories towards the end. You’ll enjoy the marvellous bursting of the dams in ‘OK’ with death metal vocals and chunky groove metal riffing at the helm. Raphaël Antheaume feels liberated on the drum stool here – listen to his astounding footwork. Likewise, the guitarists work their fretboards with more extravagance, including a harmonised solo. Observe how its follow up, ‘The Worst Is Yet to Come’, thrives on a fade in of clean arpeggios and synth drones that make way for a thumping beat of roaring vocals and head-spinning riffs.
Strip out the filler tracks scattered over this record like inconsequential flagstone puddles, and you’d have a remarkable comeback album.
JVB
Verdict


Release Date: 06/12/2024
Record Label: Season of Mist
Standout tracks: Don’t Waste Your Time; Without a Second Thought; Luke
Suggested Further Listening: Katatonia – Viva Emptiness (2003), Moonspell – Hermitage (2021), Swallow the Sun – Shining (2024)
