Pure Reason Revolution – Coming Up to Consciousness


Pure Reason Revolution have two modern classics to their name since reforming in 2018. Once a major label concern, the duo of Jon Courtney (vocals, guitar, piano, keyboards) and Chloë Alper (vocals, bass) led them to prog rock greatness for 2020’s Eupnea and again for 2022’s Above Cirrus. Now, Alper’s artistic commitments mean she cannot tour with the band at present, which led to the decision to use her live replacement, Annicke Shireen, as the recording artist on their latest LP. This makes sense on a professional level, but fans will be devastated that their heroine has no role in Coming Up to Consciousness. She hasn’t left the band, so one assumes that Courtney needed to release this record to keep his momentum going.

The shades of Radiohead and Porcupine Tree that always existed in the music of PRR are now at the forefront of their sound. Those that like the heavier side of the group will need to work hard to appreciate Jon Courtney’s piano-driven compositions on album number six. The bass and drums lock in for a rock interpretation of instrumental trip-hop in the first real song, ‘Dig Till You Die’, while Courtney fingers the piano in the gaps between his words. There’s a lot going on here, but it doesn’t feel overly busy. Annicke Shireen does a decent job deputising for the irreplaceable Alper as the soprano vocalist with a soothing presence. As if to prove their prog credentials, the band then slip into an extended offbeat rock passage at the two-minute mark. Vocal melodies float in the mix as if encouraging you to daydream. The aim here is to overwhelm you with sorrowful melodic sequences that resonate like harmless drops of water.

Placing five short interludes throughout the track listing offers little of substance or essential continuity during the listening experience. ‘Betrayal’ is the best song on the album with a Röyksopp flavour to it. Listen to the beautiful piano passages navigate through the drums and bass like swirling rays of light. You can tell that Courtney had Chloë Alper in mind when arranging the vocals lines. Again, Shireen deserves praise for the ease in which she fits into these songs with her glistening voice. The delay-drenched solo at 02:25 is simple but emotive enough to leave an impression on you. Musically, the textures conjure images of a midnight forest sparkling in the winter snow.

It’s clear as early as track number five that this is an album composed at the piano. Each song stays within the same mellifluous flow of colourful scale patterns that pinch at the listener’s heart. A Talk, Talk influence hovers in the background of ‘The Gallows’ with the use of a brooding harmonica in the transition to the song’s main dual harmony at 02:30. This is where Jon Courtney’s prog mind comes alive with the possibility of how to introduce a Rhodes piano into these soundscapes. Fans of The Verve and the latter-day works of The Arctic Monkeys could get into this as easily as the Pink Floyd brigade. You wonder if they’ll put radiant melody at the heart of everything they do. ‘Useless Animal’ threatens to be three minutes and fifty-seconds of glitter and glum tidings. Rock fans will need to take a step back and appreciate this music for its delicacy and sophistication rather than its power as a dynamic swarm of electricity. Yet you’ll find chugging riffs and blazing guitar distortion in the latter half of this composition with a triumphant return to the dual-harmony chorus at the end.

Can you recognise the natural beauty around you? Will this be enough to improve your mood? That’s a question this art poses to the listener’s imagination. Fragile guitar arpeggios flicker underneath the brave-smile vocals and latent melancholy of ‘Worship’. Courtney appears to avoid power chords for most of this record in favour of U2’s approach to forming melodies through simple high-register pickings. But then he second-guesses your instincts with a venture into the classic Smashing Pumpkins territory of heavy guitar progressions and ever-increasing tensions that will always find a release in the end

Though harsh, it’s obvious that the one weakness of Coming Up to Consciousness is that it sees itself as too mature to rock out like the last two records. It’s too solipsistic and concerned with recreating a dreamy landscape for the listener to fall into its sleepy embrace. This is more an album of self-discovery than anything else. Jon Courtney sees the key to his enlightenment through cascading piano sequences and sparse guitars. These instruments are his second voice beyond the cerebral meaning of the words. It leaves you with eyes closed for longer than they need to be as you absorb the ubiquitous melodies and try to breathe them through your lungs like the clean air of the Swiss Alps in ‘Lifeless Creature’.

Often, PRR create divine voice arrangements designed to persuade the listener that they can float away from their troubles through meditation. Courtney’s vision for this album is successful enough for you to forget where one song ends and another begins, but it owes too much of a debt to Porcupine Tree to match the band’s last two records.


Verdict


Release Date: 06/09/2024

Record Label: Inside Out Music

Standout tracks: Betrayal; Useless Animal; Worship

Suggested Further Listening: Porcupine Tree – Stupid Dream (1999), Radiohead – Hail to the Thief (2003), Manic Street Preachers – Futurology (2014)