
Ex-ISIS guitarist, Michael Gallagher, started Mustard Gas and Roses (MGR) fifteen years ago as an instrumental side project to his main band. The line-up since 2006 is more of a revolving cast of members than a permanent outfit, and this latest four-song EP is their first release since 2010.
At first glance, this seems like a jagged record. Gallagher recorded the songs back in 2017 and the final two tracks are covers of Joy Division and Spiritualised. Many musicians contributed to the recording process, but Gallagher is the pivotal musician providing guitars and vocals. Opener, ‘Shadows’, thrives on a Jane’s Addiction bass line and post-punk guitar shapes with a vocal that could be Michael Gira from Swans. On repeat listens you’ll notice subtle layers of additional guitar and will appreciate the use of dynamics to ground the composition in a more progressive framework. Just when things threaten to become reductive, Gallagher reminds us of his past with a heavy climax of sludge metal noise.
‘Becoming’ is more restrained and focused on the interplay of the acoustic guitars. Instead of strumming we get delicate plucking and a cascade of folk scales. Gallagher’s baritone voice is as much Leonard Cohen as Michael Gira here – dreamy, nicotine-coated, soothing. There’s enough tension to tease you with the prospect of drums, but they never materialise. Still, it’s an enchanting number and one that deserves five minutes of your undivided attention. Those of you with a million things to do today should use this track to unwind at the end of the evening.
Which brings us to the two cover songs. Joy Division’s ‘Exercise One’ is one of the Manchester quartet’s finest compositions, and MGR do it justice by bringing Peter Hook’s chunky bass riff even further to the fore and layering it with a nastier guitar distortion than the original. It bubbles along like a swamp and gives Gallagher an irresistible opportunity to show off the confident inflections of his baritone voice. ‘Cop Shoot Cop’ by Spiritualised is even more of a surprise with its New Orleans sound and groovy bass line. Again, Gallagher demonstrates his post-metal appreciation for loud guitar distortion in between the suave finger-clicking verses and piano splashes. The trio of female backing singers retain the gospel blues vibe of the original, yet it still feels like a Swans number from 2010’s My Father Will Guide Me up a Rope to the Sky.
The main problem with We Are One is the underwhelming nature of the record. Two new songs and two covers after a ten-year hiatus from an artist that has no stable line-up is no reason to get excited. It feels like the closure of a project that had no direction at the time and little purpose now, other than to clear the miscellaneous sound files of its creator.
A realisation this could have been so much more leaves a pang of disappointment. MGR’s music is poignant and expressive. Like a Sunday evening stroll, it pardons you from the rigours of the rat race for one precious day. But it’s not long enough. You lament that you must return to the grind of daily life tomorrow.
JVB
Verdict

Release Date: 10/11/2020
Record Label: Pax Aeternum Digital
Standout tracks: Shadows, Cop Shoot Cop
Suggested Further Listening: Joy Division – Unknown Pleasures (1979), Swans – My Father Will Guide Me up a Rope to the Sky (2010), Leonard Cohen – I’m Your Man (1988)
