
Another week, another tech metal masterpiece from Canada, as nobody ever said anywhere at any time in history. But this could be a new phenomenon. The nation famous for its rocky mountains and liberal immigration policies is already a world class hub for technical death metal in the French-speaking state of Quebec. Yet 2020 may prove to be the year of Canadian progressive metal – after all this is the land that gave us Rush and Devin Townsend.
“What’s all the fuss about?” you may ask. Well, anybody reading the latest Scream Blast Repeat reviews over the last three months will spot a trend emerging from the North American prairies, and that’s before we even mention Protest the Hero. The likes of Ancient Thrones, Without Mercy and The Myopia Condition all produced fine albums in the last few months of 2020. Now we have yet another contender for the progressive throne in the form of Vancouver debutants, Ysgaroth.
As a trio, this band generate the power and atmosphere of a unit blasting through a quarry mine with dynamite. Many bands stick the tag of ‘progressive’ on the end of their latest diluted metal release, but Ysgaroth do the opposite – they want you to feel the intensity of the extreme metal and guess which one of the thrash, death and black categories will punch you in the face on each song. It starts in an esoteric mood with ‘Rain’ creating a tapestry of bass picking and harmonised guitars to the beat of the tom drums. You know this will be an experimental album from the first 01:52 seconds of the record, but nothing will prepare you for the raw black metal of ‘Nam Gloria Satanas’, which soon morphs into a grindcore band playing the nastiest form of primitive death metal this side of 1990. For seven minutes you have no idea what is coming next, including the surprise tempo reset at the three-minute mark, which recalls Cynic at their most intricate.
The idea that we might be in for forty-nine minutes of this bewildering complexity and virtuoso musicianship can be a little intimidating. But worry not, for Ysgaroth have an evil eye for raw black metal and harsh death metal and stick to a comprehensible structure on ‘Sacred’ and ‘Altar of Scars’. Naturally, there’s no verse-chorus format in sight, but the same progressions rear their head more than once. The latter is a raw Celtic Frost/ Sodom thrash with Motorhead drums and a chugging breakdown riff in the mid-section. Perhaps the only predictable element is the sweep-picking solo, which is the minimum requirement of technical proficiency for any prog metal band these days.
With so many competing ideas locked in a permanent state of conflict, Ysgaroth recognise the challenge of maintaining coherence and intelligibility. KOSM vocalist, Jessie Grace, makes a stellar guest appearance on ‘Forward unto Death’ with her superb soprano range lending the extreme metal assault an extra layer of malevolent darkness. This is how you wanted Cradle of Filth to sound before you decided they were not for you – heavy, fast, purposeful. Ysgaroth are all of these things.
The Vancouver trio are no doubt enjoying the action on Storm Over a Black Sea. This may be why they thought it a good idea to end the album with a seventeen-minute track. Fans of Death and Enslaved are in for a treat on ‘Deluge’. No doubt about it: as a closing song, this is captivating. Shawn Hillman’s intricate bass noodling is made for a candle-lit sojourn at a masked orgy. Steve Cuddingtons’ drum work is a labyrinth of tribal patterns and vicious expeditions through the range of extreme metal’s inhuman demands. The only downside is Kurt Steigleger’s vocal performance, which lapses into a brattish punk snarl when it should be pulsating with a black metal roar, like somebody living through a disembowelment. Fortunately, his stellar guitar riffs and technical prowess on the fretboard more than compensate for this minor weakness.
Ysgaroth know Storm Over a Black Sea is a monumental journey that will test your stamina. But don’t let this deter your listening experience. This is sophisticated extreme metal that demands repeat listening.
JVB
Verdict

Release Date: 13/11/2020
Record Label: Self Released
Standout tracks: Nam Gloria Satanas, Sacred, Deluge
Suggested Further Listening: Dialogia – Nostrum (2020), Tombs – Under a Sullen Sky (2020), Ancient Thrones – The Veil (2020)
