
This reviewer will always be grateful to Cradle of Filth for keeping extreme metal alive in the barren period of the late 1990s when nu metal polluted the earth. Though they started as a black metal act and once spearheaded the genre’s intrusion into the mainstream, it’s doubtful anyone these days would associate their music with their contemporaries from that era. 2003’s epic Damnation and a Day saw them realise their dream of recording with a live orchestra (thanks to a healthy budget from Sony) and moved the band towards more of a gothic and symphonic sound. With a Grammy nomination for 2004’s Nymphetamine and a new generation of fans embracing them, they continue to mix shock rock and extreme metal while hoping their relevance to the eternal rebellion of youth culture will keep them in the public eye. 2017’s Cryptoriana – The Seductiveness of Decay charted in ten countries worldwide, which suggests they still have a hold on people’s imaginations.
As album number thirteen, Existence is Futile shows no signs of stagnation in terms of adrenaline and pomp, but it’s a long affair that could be shortened by at least twenty minutes. It’s best to split the fourteen songs into two acts, with an interregnum after track seven to stretch your limbs. Then you can allow the glory of the first half to glide you through the mayhem of ‘Existential Terror’ and ‘Necromantic Fantasies’. The former is vintage Cradle of Filth ignited by blackened death metal rhythms and Dani’s unique vocal hysterics that lie somewhere between a pig squeal and an aggressive power metal transgression. Listen to the gothic orchestration of the chorus as the fifth chords ring out behind a cacophony of symphonic arrangements – this is heavy metal at its most exciting. By contrast, ‘Necromantic Fantasies’ is a suave affair soaked in a sordid spectre of brooding string bows and pinch harmonic heroics from guitarists, Richard Shaw and Marek Šmerda. You can see why they released this as a video-single in the lead up to the album’s release.
On balance, the first half of this record is far more inventive and satisfying than the second part, thanks to the expert calibration between the technical guitar riffing and the symphonic arrangements. ‘Crawling King Chaos’ is a moody death metal piece shrouded in sinister strings and harmonic minor guitars with Dani at his most animated in the bridge and chorus. Here, the band demonstrate a veteran understanding of dynamics and aim to subjugate the listener into an agitated state of unease by using a succession of tornado shred riffs. ‘Black Smoke Curling from the Lips of War’ is even better. This one introduces a heroic melodic death metal flavour but avoids the cliches of the genre by second-guessing your instincts with a miasma of black metal posturing and female vocals ghosting in and out of the audio assault. You might even hear Paradise Lost’s gothic metal make an appearance in ‘Discourse Between a Man and his Soul’ if you listen hard enough.
The latter half of Existence is Futile has its fair share of epic melodrama and pulsating metallic moments, but the songs are longer and more formulaic. ‘The Dying of the Embers’ warrants six minutes because of the band’s generosity in allowing the guitar duo to have their moment in the spotlight with an extended lead piece. The same cannot be said of ‘Us, Dark, Invincible’ and ‘Sisters of the Mist’, two tracks that reach the repeat of the verse-bridge-chorus structure in less than two minutes and struggle in vain to stretch out the playing time for another four minutes. Only the blustery death-doom meets Judas Priest extravaganza of ‘Suffer our Dominion’ matches the glory of the first half of the record thanks to a surprise inclusion of vintage Exodus thrash and a succession of technical guitar progressions. As one of metal’s most misanthropic artists, the hyperbole surrounding the imminent climate apocalypse is perfect fodder for Dani to celebrate nature’s brutal revenge against the hubris of man on this standout composition.
As you’d expect at this stage in their career, Cradle of Filth armour their sound with all the influences from their early days of black metal to their modern status as one of the genre’s most iconic artists with a world class touring machine behind them. Closing track, ‘Unleash the Hellion’ will remind you of their late 90s symphonic black metal era with its many tremolo rhythms and savage power chords jousting with the symphonic keyboards. Here, Dani’s ferocity is just as impressive as his variation in vocal approach. Perhaps we underestimate the true power of his voice because of his outspoken personality and macabre image.
Existence is Futile might overstay its welcome towards the end, but one cannot doubt the quality of the musicianship or the ambitious vision for this record. Extreme metal is not averse to theatrics, and few do it better than Cradle of Filth.
JVB
Verdict

Release Date: 22/10/2021
Record Label: Nuclear Blast
Standout tracks: Existential Terror, Necromantic Fantasies, Black Smoke Curling from the Lips of War
Suggested Further Listening: Dimmu Borgir – Puritanical Euphoric Misanthropia (2001), Naraka – In Tenebris (2021), W.E.B. – Colosseum (2021)
