Aephanemer – Utopie


French trio, Aephanemer, are a group with a lot of promise and a lot of good will from those cheering them on from the sides. ‘The orchestral dramatics take centre stage and displace the metallic edge of the music,’ said Scream Blast Repeat about 2021’s A Dream of Wilderness. It had all the right ingredients and high levels of imagination, but it could not bring them together in a satisfying musical palate. Unfortunately, the same problems blight Utopie.

Like their cover art for this record, the Aephanemer interpretation of heavy metal is colourful. Vigorous guitars merge with orchestral string flourishes and choral keyboards in ‘Le Cimetière Marin’. Marion Bascoul is one of the most underrated vocalists in the death metal genre. Listen how she rings the words from her throat like a person undergoing an exorcism. Unfortunately, Martin Hamiche uses most of his time on the fretboard to indulge in a wet dream of stadium rock posturing. ‘La Règle du Jeu’ is quicker off the mark and more interested in matching the malevolence of the vocals. The music has a magical feel to it rather than a sinister one, and that’s a problem for anything involving a death metal component. You can’t deny the dramatic fervour or the pomp, but it’d be better if the guitar used more of the low-end power at its disposal.

We said it about this last album, and the same applies here: too much of it feels like an expedition through the magical kingdom of Narnia. Uplifting orchestrations, high tempo drums, and Yngwie Malmsteen guitar phrasing are no basis for a strong metal record. Even the headbanging moments in ‘Par-delà le Mur des Siècles’ come laced with night robes and owls when you want bayonets and human atrocities. The conductor’s baton would be useful in ‘Chimère’. Indeed, you can enjoy this song if you forget about judging it against a heavy metal benchmark. But that’s difficult when the grisly vocals are so heinous to the ears. The Disney flourishes may move your heart rate, and the timbres should invigorate you, yet you’ll feel you’ve heard everything by the end of this track.

This is a band that approach their music with the dynamics of classical music, yet ‘Contrepoint’ is neo-classical metal with no soul. There’s nothing wrong with the tempo or the thrust, but the pomp and pageantry are too much to handle. The glorious bass solo at 02:20 is a rare highlight here. And just as you’re ready to give up, Martin Hamiche digs his plectrum up and under his strings in alternate picking motion for an exercise in technical thrash metal. Now the orchestrations add an extra dimension rather than smother the primacy of the guitar. If only Side A had something like this. A simple one-note bass buildup at 04:40 sustains the momentum by recharging it from calmer waters and back into the open seas. Listen to the piano chords converse among the shredding. Part two starts at 05:33 and feels like they stitched it on from an unrelated composition. Do we need an extra three minutes of sorrowful choral samples and Beethoven interpretations of the electric guitar?

Behold the ship of gold is not a legend but a tangible reality as it comes into view on this LP. Even Disney film composers would acknowledge the talent of Martin Hamiche as a musical dramatist if you showed them the first three minutes of ‘Utopie (Partie I)’. Likewise, the metal establishment would be ready with praise for the next section if the guitar had a louder presence in the mix. But that’s the most notable weakness, and it’s even more disappointing because we expected it. The prospect of nine more minutes of this in ‘Utopie (Partie II)’ is hard to endure. Surely Aephanemer’s music needs more in the vocal repertoire than death metal voice abrasions. Weak down-picking guitar rhythms are the only low-end muscle available when spirited agitations are high.

Imagination can only get you so far if the musical execution is lacking. Clearly, Aephanemer have the tools, but they neglect some of the most powerful ones available to them on album number five.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 31/10/2025

Record Label: Napalm Records

Standout tracks: La Règle du Jeu; Contrepoint; La Rivière Souterraine

Suggested Further Listening: Amorphis – Borderland (2025), Instorm – Psycho Violence (2023), Kerberos – Apostle to the Malevolent (2025)