Klone – Meanwhile


French prog metal veterans, Klone, are the band whose name seldom appears in conversations about the genre. Formerly on the roster of Season of Mist, their 2008 classic, All Seeing Eye, will astonish you with the depth and breadth of its ambition. Nowadays, they no longer adopt the harsher vocal techniques or ramp up their guitars like Pantera, but the members of Klone never fail to surprise you with the sophistication of their art. Meanwhile is their seventh LP, and it shows once more that this group trust their evolution and that you’ll follow them to their next stage of development.

Few metal artists thrive when they step outside their comfort zone and embrace the more experimental elements of rock. Pain of Salvation and Katatonia are perhaps the two exceptions to this rule. You can now include Klone in this niche category. There is nothing lightweight or commercial about this album despite it containing as many art rock moments as metallic motifs. Opener, ‘Within Reach’, starts with ethereal keyboards and backwards noise effects before summoning a floating prog metal groove. The drums accent the guitars with illusory off kilter beats. You know within thirty seconds that this is a cerebral piece of music. Listen to the projection of Yann Ligner’s husky voice as it radiates with a latent warmth. Shades of Tesseract and Porcupine Tree dazzle in the gaps between bass and drums and in the hang of the low-treble distortion. ‘Blink of an Eye’ might even remind you of their fellow Frenchman in Hangman’s Chair. How do you describe this melancholy music? The harmony of guitar and saxophone at the beginning is what post-rock music should sound like if its more famous practitioners had a better grasp of music theory.

In the past, Klone sounded like a chunky groove metal version of King’s X with a desire to amalgamate at least four genres into every song. On this record, they trust their instincts and let the music flow with less impediments. ‘Bystander’ settles into a Pearl Jam melody of psychedelic guitars with subtle saxophone layers in the background before exploding into a drum clinic for new stickman, Morgan Berthet, to display his prog rock/jazz chops. ‘Elusive’ is more esoteric and reluctant to allow the sun to shine through the clouds despite having all the elements to do so. Imagine Talk, Talk’s 1991 record, Laughing Stock, with the guitar approach of Caligula’s Horse. The atonal guitar chords seek out more conventional melodies as the song progresses. Yes, it’s lighter and less aggressive than their earlier work, but the shroud of fog that once defined their mood is now a captivating mist. Those drumbeats are deliberate in the way they circle the guitars. Bassist, Enzo Alfano, reminds you of the band’s prog credentials every time the guitars drop the distortion for a cleaner sound. Then you can hear him work the scales like a Victorian weaver.

Most Klone albums clock in around the fifty-five-minute mark. This one is no different, yet it’s such a fascinating experience. You wonder if the band might squander their momentum at track six (‘Apnea’) when they lapse into a major key malaise, but they change to a darker passage of palm-muted guitars and intensify the aggression with a dramatic climax. Things get heavier in the second half of the LP. ‘The Unknown’ is like a crunchy metal version of Sparks until you recognise the mood as the same one embraced by Danish down-tuned rockers, VOLA. ‘Disobedience’ is a reminder that this group are still a metal band at heart. Here, the guitars chug on the open strings and let the drum groove absorb the weight of the anxiety in Ligner’s voice.

You won’t identify every nuance of this record unless you give it the attention it deserves. Every note has a deliberate intent. Every drum hit lands where it needs to be. The rhythm section challenges what each instrument can and cannot do in tandem with the others. No wonder the sound in your headphones has such a loose feel. Meanwhile is dynamic and ethereal. You can clench your fists and relax your shoulders in the same motion. Let it overwhelm you and see how it understands your mood better than you do.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 10/02/2023

Record Label: Kscope

Standout tracks: Within Reach, Blink of an Eye, Disobedience

Suggested Further Listening: Tesseract – Polaris (2015), Porcupine Tree – In Absentia (2002), VOLA – Witness (2021)