Zeal & Ardor – Zeal & Ardor


Manuel Gagneux comes from a musical family, which may explain why, like Jeff Buckley, he has that special something that distinguishes him from most other musicians. As a Swiss African American growing up with a wide variety of music, he’s just as comfortable playing indie pop and delta blues as he is blasting through a tech death or grindcore record. The inevitable slander of ‘hipster metal’ follows Zeal & Ardor around despite the critical acclaim heaped upon 2018’s Stranger Fruit. Black metal purists dislike them as much as they hate Deaf Heaven, but there’s a reason why Gagneux’s band landed the support slot on Meshuggah’s 2022 world tour. This is a fascinating piece of avant-garde metal that takes iconoclasm and subversion to new levels.

Those that liked the experimentation with black metal on previous records will lament the absence of it on this LP. Tremolo riffs and blast beats are rare here, but the extreme metal element is just as prevalent among the trip hop and gospel moments. Opener, ‘Zeal & Ardor’, subsists on ominous bass thuds and industrial beats, like Depeche Mode injected with the electro-blues of Alabama 3. Gagneux’s vocal approach will remind you of Marvin Gaye in spirit and Tom Waits in tone. You know to expect something unique with Zeal & Ardor, but this is another level. The harsh industrial metal of ‘Run’ will confuse you further. Imagine Gojira ripping through an Aborym song with demonic vocals and 4/4 beats built on the power of the rack toms.

You wonder if Zeal & Ardor’s aim is to see how far they can take the binary worlds of extreme metal and gospel blues using the common medium of industrial trip hop. This being the case, it’s an unusual vision, and one that should be difficult to put into practice. True, Gagneaux’s soulful blues voice and hand-clapping drums on ‘Death to the Holy’ are perfect for the coffee-drinking hipsters to appreciate, and his John Legend vibe on ‘Golden Liar’ is more in sop with today’s trendy middle-class connoisseurs that buy Adele records. You’re right to ask if this world can exist in a metal paradigm, and maybe it doesn’t. But that does not mean you should ignore the experimental brilliance of this record. The grindcore and shoegaze synergy of ‘Emersion’ could fit on Dillinger Escape Plan’s Ire Works masterpiece. ‘Feed the Machine’ would be ideal for a car advert were it not for the intrusion of heavy syncopated thrash riffing and goblin vocals. Zeal & Ardor are not the first to do this, when you consider the recent output of bands like Daughters. But they might be the ones to perfect this strange fusion of euphoric gospel with blackened death metal.

We need to be honest here: how much acclaim would we be giving this record if it had Mike Patton’s name on it? Mr Bungle fans will feel their inner multiple personalities beckon on the Tom Waits meets death metal chaos of ‘I Caught You’. The industrial black metal of ‘Götterdämmerung’ is worthy of Anaal Nathrakh, yet you could take any of these songs and play them on a piano. Has anyone ever tried to merge the battered soul of Otis Redding with the aggression of Mayhem and the smoke-filled blues of Nick Cave?

Not every experiment can succeed, and the Stevie Wonder-esque approach to the drop-tuned metal assault on ‘Church Burns’ will leave you with squinting eyes. Your headspace might crumble when the soundscape changes from Bergen to Mississippi at the blink of an eye. Is ‘Bow’ a shameless attempt to write the theme tune for the next Sopranos spinoff? So many questions emerge during the listening experience, yet this is never a bad thing. It’s easy to forget how heavy these songs are underneath the jaw-dropping experimentation.

The staff at SBR never dismiss an artist for being experimental or attracting an audience of people that are more likely to listen to The Strokes than Slayer. This is avant-garde metal at its most challenging and enjoyable. Where would we be if heavy music stopped embracing new art forms?

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 11/02/2022

Record Label: MVKA

Standout tracks: Run, Golden Liar, Erase

Suggested Further Listening: Bulb – Moderately Fast, Adequately Furious (2021), Alabama 3 – Exile on Coldharbour Lane (1997), Daughters – You Won’t Get What You Want (2018)