Dagoba – By Night


French industrial groove metallers, Dagoba, seem to be something of a persistent commerical hope in the industry. EMI France, Century Media and Season of Mist have all had them on their roster in the past, and now they’re back with their first album in five years on Napalm Records. Only vocalist, Pierre Maille (aka Shawter), remains from the group that formed in Marseille in 1997, yet the addition of Déluge guitarist, Richard de Mello, promises an exciting new era. So, why does By Night feel like a major label LP rather than a menacing piece of contemporary metal?

You might wonder what’s happening when you hear the pastiche of 1980s synth pop bubble through the speakers on opener, ‘Neon’. Is this a metal band or a homage to the ironic humour of Daft Punk and Les Rythmes Digitales? You receive an answer on the sci-fi metalcore expedition of ‘The Hunt’. This is what extreme metal fans want Architects to sound like – muscular, heavy on the low end, dripping in distortion, and fed through a sampling machine like Fear Factory. You cannot deny the sense of urgency, nor can you overlook the Cradle of Filth splendour at the symphonic climax. The synth-heavy loop of electronics buzzing through ‘Sunfall’ are just as exciting when spliced together with syncopated chug riffs and double-kick accents. It’s a strong start to a comeback album, so what’s the problem?

The main reservation you’ll have is the way Shawter walks straight into metalcore’s biggest cliché and most insurmountable weakness – the ubiquity of the clean rock voice in every chorus. ‘Bellflower Drive’ subsists on an impressive stomp of violent down-strumming and thumping beats, but the poppy chorus disrupts the febrile mood with an incongruous change of heart. You might think they can recover the early brilliance of this song with a heavy breakdown, but they anticipate your needs and hold back at the last moment. The same happens on the sleazy metalcore-cum-electronic pop of ‘City Lights’. One cannot deny this has an adrenaline edge to it and showcases a clean rock voice more akin to the vocal might of Greg Puciato (Dillinger Escape Plan), yet it suffers from predictability. ‘Summer’s Gone’ is merely good when it should be great. Listen to that glorious vocal roar in the middle eight. Absorb the crispy guitars and double-kick grooves – why does the melancholy chorus feel like a dampener rather than an emotional zenith?

We need more tracks like the exquisite blast of ‘The Last Crossing’. This is Dagoba at their best in a world that lies somewhere between 90s thrash and industrial. The riffs have one eye on a stadium metal arena, but the martial masculinity could tear up a DIY hardcore basement show. See if you can stay in your seat during the hurricane of frantic sixteenth-notes and high-velocity riffing – this will throw you through the air! By contrast, ‘On the Run’ slips into a contentious pop metal mediocrity. The gorgeous female vocals are too sugary and illuminous to fit into a dark vision of ringing fifth chords and creeping piano notes. Do the French quartet see their future as a Bring me the Horizon enigma or as a genre-busting metal band?

By Night is strong on dynamics and purpose, and it’s enjoyable. But it’s safe and overly polished. The Dagoba fanbase will applaud the risk-taking but might lament the intrusion of a melodious streak from the My Space era of metalcore.

At least it’ll get people talking…

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 18/02/2022

Record Label: Napalm Records

Standout tracks: The Hunt, Sunfall, The Last Crossing

Suggested Further Listening: Killer Be Killed – Reluctant Hero (2020), Killswitch Engage – The End of Heartache (2004), Arcaeon – Cascadence (2021)