Only Human – Planned Obsolescence


Danish prog metal quintet, Only Human, are not just a band. They’re a commentary on our era of big tech dominance and our offloading of critical thinking to AI apps. Formed in 2022 as an online collaboration, they signed to Season of Mist at the beginning of this year, and the French label have big plans for them. Their talent is not in question, but Planned Obsolescence does not quite live up to its promise as a piece of art.

The ominous keyboard notes in the intro to ‘Drift’ warn of a dystopian future ahead. Its cinematic sense of place is impressive, even when the introspective vocals enter. But this is prog metal, which means the drummer lays down an extended groove as the words drift like paper in the wind. Why does it feel longer than two minutes before the guitars erupt in a wave of distortion? Patrick Grønbæch Christensen demonstrates a strong growling voice here when decibel levels intensify, but the linear structure of the song leaves you wondering how to get the most out of it on a second and third listen.

Melody does not intimidate this band, nor does trying to capture the ethereal heaviness of Tesseract in ‘The Sun and the Moon’. Christensen has the capability to lead the way with his anguished tenor voice, but it’s surprising how little his bandmates layer the guitars and atmospherics in the background. You want the dynamics to break free of the contrast between bliss and blistering distortion. Where are the riffs? Why are there no tempo changes? Fortunately, ‘Steep Descent’ shows they can write a riff even if it comes close to imitating ‘Ticks and Leeches’ by Tool. Again, the main content seems stuck in an inflexible bubble where time stands still, and the outside world is beyond reach. Yet the robotic voice effects will make your eyes twitch.

Clearly, this group have some good ideas, but the delivery is subdued despite some remarkable vocal gymnastics. Is it acceptable to plunge your plectrum in down-strumming motion for most of the action when you’re playing guitars with extra strings? ‘Death Cult’ is what alternative rock would sound like today if remade by Tesseract and Pain of Salvation for a collaborative charity single. With a title like ‘Techno Fascist’, you hope this effort will be as keen to push the aggro as its name suggests. Two minutes of maudlin loneliness do the opposite of what you want, though the axemen threaten a gravity-defying barrage of riffing at various points during the six minutes of underwhelming action. Be decisive, boys – why not go full Meshuggah if it’s at the back of your mind? A tasty solo is yet another indication of the talent at the heart of this band, but the rhythm guitars lack imagination.

As if listening to these concerns, they start ‘Automata’ like Northlane at their most epic. Here, cascading guitar shapes imitate synthesisers in the tension of the verse parts and keep you guessing when the release might arrive. Christensen’s reverb-heavy whispers and dormant aggression give the vocal lines a wonderful rhythm that could lead any Caligula’s Horse song. But too much time spent staring at clean white walls can lead to self-doubt. On a musical level, ‘Aspire’ does just that, though you can find a sideshow in the terrific hi-hat patterns and laddering solo if needed.

The end to this record is much more enthralling. Closing track, ‘Breach’, is the type of industrial prog metal made famous on Meshuggah’s None EP in 1994. Can you feel the might of the chunky chords and the jagged sequences loop around you like machines lined up in a perimeter of manufacturing operations?

Only Human are at the beginning of their career, and they have an abundance of potential like the tech unicorns that proliferated through Silicon Valley in the 2010s. But will they be here to tell the tale in five years’ time?

Kirk Houghton


Verdict