Green Carnation – A Dark Poem, Part I: The Shores of Melancholia


Norway’s Green Carnation are no strangers to ambition. Their 2001 sophomore album, Light of Day, Day of Darkness, is a one-hour song of longform storytelling built around a gothic doom framework and interspersed with female operatic vocals, a children’s choir, saxophone furnishings, and a Hammond organ (not to mention a vocoder). Their reformation in 2014 and comeback LP of 2020 hinted that they might be ready to follow up their 2001 magnus opus with something as ambitious. They’ve now clarified their vision: A Dark Poem, Part 1 is the first in a trilogy of albums to be released by Season of Mist. We could be in for something special.

A vigorous doom metal riff opens the gates to a world of heavy snare beats and nocturnal keyboard atmospherics in opener, ‘As Silence Took You’. There’s no doubt we’re listening to a prog metal song when Kjetil Nordhus’ eloquent storytelling vocals lead the first verse like a bearded sage reflecting on his prophecies. The juxtaposition between thick guitar riffing and melodic singing in a high baritone range is its strongest feature. Nordhus has a wonderful way of expressing his words with the lucidity of a folk singer. Listen how he and the band navigate the bridge to the chorus like Queensrÿche undergoing a key change. Unlike the former, they love to chug on their guitars, which puts them in the same domain as Dream Theater.

In the same spirit, they marshal through ‘In Your Paradise’ as if warming up for a tour of Germany with English heroes, Threshold. Observe how the simple pentatonic riff in the undercurrent combines with flourishing strings and then follows the vocal phrasing in the chorus. Nordhus’ command of the words is impressive for somebody up against a wall of distortion. Instead, he uses it to elevate him without giving in to the easy option of barking the lyrics into the microphone. You assume a mellifluous guitar solo will emerge from the drama of the middle-eight, but they introduce the flute of Ingrid Ose for additional colouring. Only at the end, do they converge on a head-spinning metal riff for the raised fists of a festival crowd.

The bending notes of the bass take control of ‘Me, My Enemy’ like a first officer taking over from the captain of the aircraft. Swishing oscillating effects and emotive guitar weeping lead the way for Nordhus to enter with a clenched jaw. “Listen, out here we’re vulnerable / Life here could cut us off / When we are on their grounds,” cries the Norwegian. It ought to be a predictable song when we learn the first chorus revolves around ringing chords and slow-motion drums, but the organ in the background and angular phrasing of the bass offer a welcome diversion from the obvious. Can you feel the heat of your hand on your bosom as you absorb the emotions of the story unfolding? If so, it won’t last long. ‘The Slave That You Are’ is the gruesome surprise of the album with Grutle Kjellson of Enslaved leading them into a black metal tailspin. Drummer, Jonathan Alejandro Perez, excels here in the blast beats and at the double-kick drum for the verses. Even here, Nordhus takes over for the chorus with the same melodic awe despite his entry point arriving after a vicious spiral of Emperor riffing. The nod to Black Sabbath in the middle-eight comes plated with celestial keyboards where you expect a grunting bass guitar.

Who remembers when Queensrÿche used to write songs with this level of perspicacity? The instruments are but props to bring a story to life, which is one of the hardest things to do in heavy metal when the guitars demand centre stage and the drums can introduce an element of excess force. “Here on the shores of melancholia / Winter is draining the life out of summer and hope torn asunder,” laments Nordhus in a sorrowful voice not yet denuded of hope in the chorus for ‘The Shores of Melancholia’.

If you can’t sing along to this album after one listen, you’re not paying attention. Throughout it all, the focus remains on raising the anthems to levels of empowerment that seldom define heavy metal these days. The magnificent range of colours and disciplined attachment to the muscular guitars of metal have set a high standard for Part 2.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 05/09/2025

Record Label: Season of Mist

Standout tracks: In Your Paradise; The Slave that You Are

Suggested Further Listening: Pain of Salvation – The Perfect Element I (2000), Queensrÿche – Digital Noise Alliance (2022), Threshold – Dividing Lines (2022)