
Scotland has heavyweight artists in most rock and metal genres, not least in progressive post-metal (Dvne), metalcore (Bleed from Within), avant-garde metal (Ashenspire), mathcore (Frontierer) and grindcore (Gendo Ikari). It also has one of the most vibrant death metal scenes in Europe. Ihlo announced their presence on the prog metal scene in 2019 with their acclaimed Union LP, and they’ve used the last six years to perfect their sophomore effort. It comes in at one hour and eight minutes and challenges the boundaries of virtuosity, but is it a new beginning for the genre or a homage to the greats we’ve grown to love over the last fifteen years?
Of course, it doesn’t need to be a choice between innovation and consolidation of existing musical ideas. That would be a harsh dichotomy to use for an album review. It’s clear in the opening minute of ‘Wraith’ that sound design is as important as technical guitar passages and off-meter drum patterns. Andy Robison’s tenor range is similar (but not identical to) Daniel Tompkins of Tesseract, and this’ll be a constant comparison you should try to avoid while absorbing this record. Here, the mellifluous symmetry of the synthesiser opens the vistas to a prog metal conundrum using the inevitable Meshuggah approach to rhythm and groove. Yet the transition points are just as ambitious as Leprous in their melodic reach. Guitar solos of modal perfection light the way like urban illuminations as the drums reverberate and add fills as skilfully as a train navigating the desolate landscape of Siberia. Describing every peak and trough in the seven minutes here is a futile exercise. All you need to know are the timbres, and these are bright yellow, orange and green. Stargazing with a telescope would be the ideal accompaniment to this song.
The vocal arrangements receive most of the attention in ‘Replica’ as the clean guitar arpeggios diverge from the burrowing bass groove. This is one of the few times when the drop-tuned crunch of the chorus deserves a comparison with Tesseract. Ihlo remind us here that they appreciate the dynamism of prog metal as much as the mysticism of electronic pop. Listen how the snare remains in the pocket while every other instrument thrives at full capacity. “I’ve got nothing left to give / So take what’s left and bury me / I’m broken to the core,” cries Robison at the highest threshold of his emotive tenor voice.
Though you’ll find plenty of spaces in the songs, Ihlo like to fill them with synthesisers. Programmed drums in mono set the scene for ‘Source’. This is what separates Ihlo from Caligula’s Horse and the others in contemporary prog rock and metal: they emphasise the importance of electronics in their music. Clearly, Robison enjoys the challenge of minimalist electronic layers to propel his voice to higher dimensions rather than relying on the distortion of a guitar to guide him. Yet the gliding riffs are most welcome when they step on the overdrive and make the shapes contort to the rhythm of the drum groove. Here, they thunder with a low-tuned crunch worthy of English prog heroes, Threshold. Every head will be circling in approval when they play this at The Black Heart in Camden on 20 September for the album release show.
‘Mute’ at track six would be the natural demarcation point for Side B, but the compositions become longer in the second half, averaging eight minutes in length between track five and ten. This’ll intimidate the most experienced of prog lovers who can see beyond self-indulgence and excess, and it’s surprising that they start this part of the record in a more sedate mode. Clean guitars and calm drums sit in the background while Robison tells us that he “cannot stop the aching in my life,” while giving us an advanced look at the techniques available for future one-to-one singing lessons. Musically, it’s one of the few times they ought to have edited three minutes out of a song and cut to the eruption of distortion at the finale with more haste. Yet they’re back on track in the next effort, ‘Cenotaph’, with an overflow of drop-tuned guitar posturing and incredulous vocals that react to the phenomenon of the natural world around them in awe. Unfortunately, this is another moment when you cannot erase the thought that it’s an unreleased track from the last Tesseract album.
You might wonder if they’ve forgotten about the listener at track eight (see ‘Haar’) as they lose themselves in an ocean of expressive melodies wrapped in subtle offbeats. Its successor, ‘Legacy’ is a fine effort, but it feels like a second attempt to outdo Periphery’s iconic ‘Satellites’ song from 2019 after already broaching the possibility on ‘Cenotaph’. By contrast, the melodic sophistication of the riffing in ‘Empire’ could grace any of the first five King’s X albums or their modern equivalent in Haken’s last run of four LPs. Robison’s breath control is remarkable in the way he can push through the octaves and come back down again in the line of a stanza. Likewise, the lock-in between Clark McMenemy (drums) and Phil Monro (guitars) for the circular rhythms shows an advanced variation of mood between enlightening melody and aggressive force with the synths leading the extravagance when it’s time to surrender to the celestial beauty.
An album’s brilliance must stand on the quality of its last quarter. The waterfall of colourful guitar arpeggios in closing track, ‘Signals’, are good enough to open the record. Listen to the melancholia rise like a pleasant steam against the forehead. The way Ihlo replace this in the same key at 03:06 with a circuitous synth is sensational. Can you feel your body loosening under the radiance as it expels the last traces of stress from its pores? Seldom is this the dominant sensation in prog metal, but Legacy is a long-play piece of art that deserves multiple listens for maximum enjoyment.
JVB
Verdict


Release Date: 29/08/2025
Record Label: Kscope
Standout tracks: Replica; Empire; Haar
Suggested Further Listening: Tesseract – PORTALS (2021), Omnerod – The Amensal Rise (2023), Kingcrow – Hopium (2024)
