
Ask your average metal fan to name the first metalcore band that comes to mind, and they’ll often say Killswitch Engage. And with good reason. Before 2002’s groundbreaking Alive or Just Breathing album, metalcore existed as a niche within the underground and had no vision of what it might achieve. This Massachusetts changed all that. Thrash metal riffing, hardcore vocals and anthemic choruses stormed into the mainstream at the right time. Within ten years, you could not move for the number of Killswitch Engage clones. But this also saw the genre absorb a litany of clichés. Everybody copied the good cop-bad cop vocals of Jesse Leach (and his one-time replacement, Howard Jones), most of them turning the latter into something you might hear at a Blink 182 concert. Likewise, the breakdown ritual became a permanent feature of heavy music, yet it sometimes took priority over songwriting for those late to the party. Metalcore is in a mediocre place right now, but that should not discourage you from plugging into the latest record from the genre’s pioneers.
Ripping through ten songs in thirty-five minutes is not the most obvious way to reclaim your crown for album number nine. But it’s a wise decision here. Opener, ‘Abandon Us’, is seething thrash metal from the first palm-muted chug. It relies on sinister roars and clear double-kick action from the drummer. Jesse Leach sounds infuriated right up until he switches to his clean vocals for the chorus. As the man who popularised this in the genre, he must be incensed that so many copied him and turned his style into a whiny teenage angst voice that he does not possess. Of course, the key question is, “Are they doing anything new in this song or anything that sounds like it emerged pre-2003?” No, but it’s clever to start your new LP with a winning formula. The questions come later in the album.
Perhaps the biggest triumph of This Consequence is the way it avoids surprises and focuses on quality. Though a risky strategy, it serves them well. Sometimes, it makes sense to give the people what they want. The energy and intensity of ‘Discordant Nation’ and ‘Aftermath’ are admirable. Indeed, the former would be even better if it avoided the predictable chorus, but this is too radical an idea to contemplate. Keep this effort confined to a harsh vocal approach and it could easily sit on the same stage as classic Machine Head.
Those jaded by this type of music will be surprised by its potency. Killswitch Engage show how metalcore could’ve conquered the gatekeepers’ world if their imitators had learned the right lessons from this music. The axemen revel in the death metal tremolos for the chorus to ‘Aftermath’. Blast beats reverse the melodic dominance of at least two chorus singalongs on this record. ‘Forever Aligned’ is a wonderful mix of Meshuggah’s staccato thrash with Faith No More’s famous chorus modulations.
But do the choruses become tiresome? Not quite. You know they lie in wait, boxed up and ready to go in each song. ‘I Believe’ is how to turn Iron Maiden into a metalcore act. The heavy parts of ‘Collusion’ are chunky enough to plant a permanent gurn on your face and make you forget the melodic sauntering. They hint that they might even ditch the radio rock chorus in ‘Where It Dies’, drawing their knives from the inspiration of Slayer’s Hell Awaits era. Alas, they keep it in their structure.
This Consequence is a crushing album with a stubborn need to avoid anything too imaginative. Drums batter your ears like a biblical storm. Guitars crunch like steel mallets reshaping new materials. Words writhe in anger and regret. The death metal riffing, harmonic minor scales and blast beats at the heart of ‘The Fall of Us’ are one of the few exceptions to a formula they know so well. Even so, you’re not disappointed by this LP.
JVB
Verdict


Release Date: 21/02/2025
Record Label: Metal Blade
Standout tracks: Abandon Us; Where It Dies; The Fall of Us
Suggested Further Listening: Bleed from Within – Fracture (2020), Product of Hate – You Brought This War (2021), Bury Tomorrow – Cannibal (2020)
