The Halo Effect – March of the Unheard


Is there a band that carved out a more alarming downward trajectory since the year 2000 than In Flames? These days, the Swedish melodeath pioneers specialise in mediocrity and disappointing their fans, which makes the case for The Halo Effect even stronger. What could be a better alternative than In Flames alumni forming their own supergroup to show how melodic death metal ought to be done? Unfortunately, their 2022 debut, Days of the Lost, did little to lift excitement levels, and album number two is just as bland. Nay, it might even be worse. Why is this music so inconsequential?

If albums can fall into cliché, then, so can album reviews. Guess what? This album starts well enough… Blah, blah, blah. A mellifluous synth opens proceedings in ‘Conspire to Deceive’ and traces the outline of the main guitar riff in the intro. As usual, nobody can fault the acerbic vocals of Mikael Stanne or the exciting tempo of the music. The sense of heroism and willingness to hear the call to arms are two things that define the emotions of this art. Daniel Svensson makes the most of his time on the drum stool by inserting fills left, right and centre. Finger-tapped guitar patterns swirl through the mix like a sparkle of fireflies. But you must sit through another eleven songs like this.

The weakness of the melodic death metal genre soon becomes apparent at track two (see ‘Detonate’). This is classic In Flames with a thrash metal pace and an extravaganza of harmonised riffing. Here, the guitars take centre stage with raucous drums in pursuit. But there’s a problem.  Take out the vocals and this is melodic rock music. ‘Our Channel to the Darkness’ is another false friend. We already know the ingredients – anthemic choruses, chivalrous stadium rock guitars, colourful melodies, growled vocals, and aggressive drums.

The irony is that Chuck Schuldiner – the godfather of death metal – ended up preferring this type of music with its nod to Iron Maiden and Judas Priest and pretensions to replace the old heavy metal elite with something heavier. If only that was the case here. Instead, The Halo Effect show on ‘Cruel Perception’ and ‘What We Become’ that they can write this music in their sleep. Even the lyrics are tiresome. “We must endure / Unpack our failures / Resist the hardship at the onset / Take to the argument.” Unlike hardcore, which avoids ambiguity but speaks about universal human themes, this music obscures them in a relativism that has meaning to everyone and no one.

One cannot doubt that the veterans of The Halo Effect perfected this musical style back in the late 1990s, but it’s now too predictable, like an aging centre-left politician who pretends to identify with the latest progressive cause to maintain his consistency and public profile. Can you distinguish the title-track from any of the other cuts on Side A? This is the safest hard rock music you’ll find that understands the importance of baring its teeth. It creates the illusion of passion and empowerment. Mikael Stanne must be in two minds about the impact it has on his creativity. On the one hand, he finds it easy to add his impressive vocals; on the other, he must wonder if it’s right that it comes so easy to him.

Side B of this record is unlistenable. That’s because its blandness comes to the surface once you see past the exciting tempo and flamboyant fretwork. It’s like giving a guitar to Tom Morello and asking him to create six pentatonic blues riffs in sixty seconds – he’ll thank you for giving him such an easy task and assume you’re impressed by his creations. Only one track leaves a mark at this stage. ‘Between Directions’ is like Hetfield and Hammett locked into an Iron Maiden wet dream. You can tap your foot in the syncopated bridge to the chorus. The keyboard strings add an extra dimension in the clean singing. To be fair, its successor, ‘A Death That Becomes Us’, almost succeeds with a rare chugging riff, but this effort is formulaic enough for you to forget the clever change of key for the chorus.

This band are quite capable of producing the same album next year in fulfilment of their contract with Nuclear Blast. But does the metal world need yet another soulless melodic death record?

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 10/01/2025

Record Label: Nuclear Blast

Standout tracks: Conspire to Deceive; Between Directions

Suggested Further Listening: In Flames – Colony (1999), Darkane – Expanding Senses (2002), Callenish Circle – Flesh_Power_Dominion (2002)