Charles East – Dislocated


South African singer-songwriter, Charles East, plays piano-driven post-rock that some people call piano doom. There’s no doubt it has an experimental streak. As a classically trained musician, his talent is easy to identify when you listen to his debut album. This man sings with the confidence of an A Cappello vocalist even though his songs love to build layers of instrumentation.

Amp feedback introduces a splash of piano and palm-muted guitar chords in opener, ‘It Holds my Viscera’. East places his voice in the middle of this with elongated techniques and emotes like Matt Bellamy of Muse. Hark how the drums simmer along in the mix as if brought to life by a jazz sticksman. Listen to the words oscillate. It’s unusual to write downtempo rock music with piano leading the way and guitars providing the muscle.

Creative ideas come easy to Charles East, but a grasp of Western song structures does not, although this may be deliberate. His voice is strong in ‘Venom’ and ‘I am the Plague’ but not as memorable as it could be. Electric guitars drone in the background during the heavier moments of the former. The latter sees humming machine effects and violent smashing noises lay down the beats. East prefers to be in a minimalist setting here to communicate his emotions in a distinctive tenor shiver. But it sounds like a man moaning for most of the song. Ironically, his guitarwork bites with more venom here. Imagine Jeff Buckley with a gothic metal band behind him.

There’s no big push for a chorus with a change of vocal phrasing in many of these efforts. You’d mistake ‘Is this my Doom?’ for directionless music if it wasn’t so linear. Here, a spooky piano motif conjures images of an attic covered in cobwebs. Few of the vocal lines stay inside your head. East pushes his voice through the cracks and stays in tune, but the words lose impact under the strain. Though the excess use of vibrato in ‘Diseased’ is too irksome for these ears, others might enjoy it. A cello adds to the misery of this composition. You can hear him inhale before each line, and one cannot deny the talent on display.

Radiohead fans will appreciate the combination of piano, tom drums and shuddering vocals in ‘I am your Consequence’. You can find moments of genuine brilliance if you persevere. ‘Resting in my Blood’ is the definition of a gothic serenade with Christian Death 1334 vocalist, Eva. O, wailing in the background. The transition to a crunchy metal rhythm at 01:30 is an intelligent way to release the shaky tension created by East’s vocal style.

As an album with many risks and too much eclecticism, Dislocated falls short because of its art-school pretensions. East has the technique but not enough vocal charisma to pierce your heart. He’s like a supreme writer with fundamental weaknesses as a storyteller. Listen how a cabaret vibe emanates from the playful end track but soon falls into a manic depression. East reconfigures the second half of this composition as a rock opera to second-guess your instincts, but you lament how many of the words suffer under the fragile shudder of his emotive (but disconcerting) voice.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 17/12/2024

Record Label: Brucia Records

Standout tracks: I am the Plague; I am your Consequence; Damnation

Suggested Further Listening: Thom Yorke – Tomorrow’s Modern Boxes (2014), Duncan Evans / Wilderness Hymnal – Until Liars Fear You (2021)