Cathari – It Will Hurt the Entire Time You Are Alive


Philadelphia’s Cathari are a transitional band in more ways than one. The vocalist from the group’s 2019 Corporeality debut went by the name of Mac Stephens, and they played a melancholy doom rock like Pallbearer. Now, they return with Magdalena Stephens in her new gender and seem to have spent the last two years listening to Ken Mode and Couch Slut. The change in sound is enough to make you check if it’s the same band. Out go the ten-minute ruminations and in come new forms of chaos.

A cloud of feedback introduces a grotty distortion of guitars and mid-range tuning of drum snares in opener ‘Philadelphia’ as you wait for the group’s trademark sorrow to work its way into your system. It doesn’t. Instead, they deliver a shapeless noise that belches with a death metal malevolence and seethes with hardcore fervour. Listen how the bass gurgles underneath the action like the slow-beating heart of a wounded shepherd. Magdalena takes aim at the shallowness of the Philadelphia music scene: “Carrying around all this pain is a full time job and you still gotta make yourself a living, while everyone around you would slit their mother’s throat just to play a “big show” where they make a hundred bucks and get respect from a band with an exploitative label deal and a cargo van with a bed bunk.” Ouch! You’d think the lyrics were about surviving a sex trafficking ring judging by the pain of the vocal screams. Those expecting Porcupine Tree will need to brush up on their Pupil Slicer.

Few bands make the transition from introspective rock to extreme noise, and this might explain why this music is so hard to fathom on first listen. Cathari don’t write riffs; they construct traumas with electric guitars. With no tradition in this type of aggressive metallic hardcore, Stephenson and Co. are free from overthinking or caring about what their audience expects. ‘It Will Hurt’ is like a hardcore band that could take the stage next to a goregrind artist without knowing of their similarities. Think of it as Agnostic Front riffing with chaotic blast beats and blood-dribbling vocals. The mix is sludgy and proud to be messy. A hint of melody emanates from the amps with seventh chords encased in heavy amp gain. This feels like a therapy session in which the patient drops the façade of stability and breaks down into tears.

Might we call the new Cathari approach malevolent noise rock? Guitarist, Kevin Nolan, aims to make a mockery of the traditional scales by fretting combinations that clash like vinegar and cooking oil in standout song, ‘Weight’. An unhinged spoken word rears its head in between the frothing voice projections. Imagine Henry Rollins fronting a post-black metal band. “I won’t ever make the same mistake with you,” screeches Magdalena in remembrance of a narcissist who used to be her friend. The belting rasp of her voice in ‘Don’t Fear Death’ makes you believe that she has splints in her fingernails. This is blackened hardcore with rough guitars and overpowering drums. You could argue that the lack of technicality enhances the music – there’s no time for flamboyance or showmanship with so much vitriol waiting to come out.

Cathari might not know where their music will take them or even have the tools to continue this trajectory into something more tangible, but their integrity is not in doubt. Their transition is extreme, but it’s hard to ignore.


Verdict


Release Date: 24/05/2024

Record Label: Self-released

Standout tracks: Weight, Don’t Fear Death

Suggested Further Listening: Couch Slut – You Could Do It Tonight (2024), Immortal Bird – Thrive on Neglect (2019), Child – Shitegeist (2024)