
‘Voyeurist feels like a Deftones White Pony era take on the metalcore genre with a dose of fin de millennium Radiohead in the background. It’s angry, moody, jagged, and noisy, yet the quality of songwriting stands out above everything,’ said Scream Blast Repeat of the last Underoath LP in 2022. They’re now ready to unleash album number ten on a new label (MNRK Heavy), and it’s a lot more direct and determined to avoid anything that does not suit the song. Yet there’s something missing from this effort.
Naturally, it starts with all guns blazing. This is sensible for a metalcore band that still appeal to the post-hardcore crowd. ‘Generation No Surrender’ is how you take the Dillinger Escape Plan and retool their sound as a chugging drop-tuned whirl of chaos camouflaged in a groove. It’s heavy enough to give you a receding hairline. Spencer Chamberlain might be left with bloodshot eyes based on the force of his screaming. Here, guitars lock in with half-timing drums in the mosh parts and ring out like alarm clocks when the plectrums pick at the natural harmonics on the fretboard. If the breakdown at the end doesn’t decapitate you, nothing will. “It’s us versus them,” is the message.
The first three tracks offer a ruthless display of aggression. ‘Devil’ sees fast sliding chords battle against voice loops and syncopated bass shapes. It’s like At the Drive In beefed up with a metallic guitar tone. Yet the band concentrate on providing the listener with an anthemic chorus to shout back at them in ‘Loss’. “You can lie, and you can tell that I am doomed, and I don’t know myself,” roars Chamberlain in the former.
But, of course, this is Underoath, and they’re not scared to experiment with atypical vocal melodies and dance beats. Chamberlain’s high-pitched screaming might alienate those that like masculine grunting and growling in their heavy music, but it suits the mood for most of this record. Unfortunately, things go off course from ‘Survivor’s Guilt’ (track four) onwards. The is the first outright attempt to use guitar glitches and agitated beats for a hard-edged pop song. Is the aim here to write something memorable without relying on breakdowns and blistering riffs? The two-beat drum pattern in the chorus could be from any Taylor Swift album. Maybe this explains the detour in the mid-section through loud and hostile chords and accelerated screams. ‘Teeth’ is just as baffling. They seem confident that they can write an off-beat R&B number to show how much they’ve learned over the last twenty-six years. It’s a common mistake in heavy music to think that pop music can be turned into something subversive and accessible at the same time. Put a young Mike Patton in front of this, and it might work, but he’d do it with no sense of seriousness and give it more soul.
Look beneath the surface and you’ll find enough material on The Place After this One to warrant an approving nod of the head. But we need more bangers like ‘And Then There Was Nothing’ and the album opener, ‘Generation No Surrender’. The former is back to the overheated boiler room for a combustible rage of down-tuned guitars and hysterical fry screams. Chamberlain’s lyrics make you understand why the group discarded the melodic chorus option here: “If I kept on living your way, I’d be six feet underneath / No, I didn’t keep a single thing / It was all so fucked.”
“Everybody, everybody on your knees!” declares the Underoath frontman in ‘Shame’. But why ruin this with a throwaway boy-band verse before redeeming some credibility in the chorus? It threatens to go berserk again in the middle section, but they’re too quick to revisit the conventional bridge-chorus structure and get to the end of the song. By contrast, Enter Shikari linger over ‘Vultures’ like it’s the mid-2000s again. It’s strange that they asked Troy Sanders of Mastodon to appear on this specific track.
Underoath still have that ability to keep you engaged through their unpredictability and threats to rip your face off. You’d appreciate it if they could do more of the latter after psyching you up to levels of adrenaline worthy of strapping in for a rollercoaster ride. Lead single, ‘All the Love Is Gone’, is a good guide to this record. Put it on alternative or rock radio in 2005, and it’d be a hit – but that was twenty years ago.
JVB
Verdict


Release Date: 28/03/2025
Record Label: MNRK Heavy Records
Standout tracks: Generation No Surrender; All the Love Is Gone; And Then There Was Nothing
Suggested Further Listening: August Burns Red – Leveler (2011), Fit for a King – The Hell We Create (2022), Architects – The Sky, The Earth & All Between (2025)
