
The Halo Effect are an unusual proposition. All five members played in Gothenburg legends, In Flames, at one point of their career. Indeed, rhythm guitarist, Niclas Engelin, was still in the band as late as last year. You’ll know Mikael Stanne as the frontman of Dark Tranquillity but might not remember that he performed session vocals on 1993’s Lunar Strain. With such pedigree, it’s no surprise that Nuclear Blast signed them to their roster upon their formation last year. Worshippers of Sweden’s glory days of melodic death metal in the 1990s will greet The Halo Effect with the alacrity of an early Christmas. Those of you that gave up on the genre after In Flames evolved into an alternative metal act in 2002 will have few reasons to return to the fold.
The prospect of a thrash metal supergroup featuring former members of Anthrax and Megadeth would excite the nerves like a penis injection, so why does the same not apply to The Halo Effect? That might be because melodic death metal never achieved the heights of thrash metal or experienced the cyclical regression of a popular sub-culture. Instead, melodic death metal’s long-drawn-out saturation is a process that started in the mid-2000s without reaching a mainstream peak. The formula of Iron Maiden mixed with Death and the histrionics of stadium metal grow stale once you’ve heard an album from each of At the Gates, Dark Tranquillity and Soilwork. All the bands that copy these pioneers ensured that this type of music became sterile and uninteresting within a decade. But what about when today’s creators are the original innovators?
Album opener, ‘Shadowlands’, is a reminder that rapid tempos and fast heartbeats are essential ingredients to the Gothenburg sound. Add in the updated NWOBHM riffs and growls of death metal, and you have a song that cannot fail to get you moving. Of course, the sparkling harmonised guitar heroics are never far away, making their appearance as early as track two on this record. The footwork from drummer, Daniel Svensson, is exquisite but so is the technical timekeeping in power metal, and we don’t celebrate that as an innovative genre of music, do we?
‘The Needless End’ is an early poser of the question that can guide you through Days of the Lost – would this be acceptable on a modern Carcass album? Given the predictability of the choruses and the obsession with writing anthems for a stadium metal circuit, the answer is no. Yet the magnificent vocal enunciation and shredding guitars sway you in the other direction. ‘In Broken trust’ emancipates far beyond its self-imposed boundaries and into gothic metal territory with a surprise use of clean vocals in the chorus. ‘Gateways’ coalesces around a Rammstein chorus chant with alt-rock strumming and hairy bassline patterns for the verse parts. More of these nuggets would be welcome, but they prefer to deliver the formula that served them best in the 1990s on ‘A Truth Worth Lying For’ and ‘Feel What I Believe’. It makes for a predictable onslaught that gleams with the right colours and pulsates with the right intensity, yet it never feels ugly or transgressive. This is death metal for God’s sake! We don’t want crisp drums and pristine guitar distortion. Admittedly, the band’s unwillingness to incorporate the modern fad for exploring dissonant chords works in their favour on Days of the Lost, but there’s nothing new here, either.
Is it enough to celebrate the pedigree of a band and the superb musicianship they bring to the studio when judging an album of this importance? You’ll find nothing to criticise if melodic death metal is your forte, but those of you less inclined to dip into this niche genre will remember why you last paid attention to it twenty years ago.
JVB
Verdict

Release Date: 12/08/2022
Record Label: Nuclear Blast
Standout tracks: Shadowminds, In Broken Trust, Gateways
Suggested Further Listening: Arch Enemy – Deceivers (2022), Darkane – Inhuman Spirits (2022), Ancient Settlers – Our Last Eclipse: “The Settlers Saga Pt.1” (2022)
