The Defaced – Charlatans


Swedish post-thrash quartet, The Defaced, went their separate ways in 2008 after their Anomaly LP. Klas Ideberg (rhythm guitar) and Jens Broman (vocals) had interests in the more prominent Darkane, who were signed to Nuclear Blast at the time. As so often happens, life got in the way over the next decade. Broman left Darkane and retired from music in 2011. The Defaced’s main songwriter, Mattias Svenson, kept himself busy with Helsingborg thrashers, Kayser. It took the Covid-19 lockdown for the members of the group to reassess their legacy and ask the daunting question – do we still have that special something?

Opener, ‘Monochromatic Void’, suggests The Defaced’s first instinct is to pick up where they left off in 2008. Broman’s voice is stronger and more purposeful than ever in its husky pitch, while Ideberg and Svenson’s guitars are crunchier than a rack of barbecue ribs. You’ll hear the guiding hand of Machine Head in the heavier parts, but it sounds closer to the thrash metal of the 1990s when titans like Testament and Kreator had to adapt to the dominance of grunge by down-tuning their guitars. Or perhaps Fates Warning is a better comparison. Like those heavy metal stalwarts, The Defaced threaten to explore progressive territory within the framework of their conventional structures.

‘Bleeding Ore’ is a fine song and one that might appeal to people whose tastes in heavy music go no further than Alice in Chains. You’ll find a contemplative hard rock odyssey behind those chugging guitars and pounding drums. Indeed, you’re unsure whether to call it hard rock or metal throughout most of the record. ‘Charlatan’ is like Shadows Fall thrash circa 2009, while ‘Wreck’ is the sort of muscular groove metal that would have slipped into the mainstream in 2001 with a good run on MTV2. It’s pejorative to see a virtue in a thrash band turning to hard rock for inspiration thanks to the disastrous experience of Metallica in the 1990s, but ‘Celestial Display’ gives a blueprint for how to do it. Keep the chunky alt-picking riffs, retain the double-kick eighth notes, and nail the chorus like you have John Bush (Armored Saint/ex-Anthrax) behind the mic. Though not a formula many will want to revisit, it works in this context.

You can see why Svenson and Broman connected during their initial writing sessions in 2020. The songs flow like unimpeded traffic on a long stretch of motorway. Every track has a powerful chorus and meaty riff to back it up. ‘Son of the Sun’ establishes a perfect equilibrium between octave chords and palm-muted open notes and allows Broman to demonstrate a more emotive side to his gravel-throated voice. Consistency is the greatest asset of this record, but it also raises the issue of searching for something – anything – that’s extraordinary. ‘Enter the Stage’ is a competent song, but it sounds like the wave of homogenous American bands that emerged in the aftermath of Alice in Chains’ commercial success in the early 1990s. ‘No More Diamonds’ uses Metallica’s clever trick of cutting out the distortion for the chorus just like ‘Unforgiven’, but you wonder if today’s youth will see it as anything other than the ‘dad rock’. They don’t scream on any of these tracks, and that’s why the younger generation will make the myopic judgement that this music is not for them. But it is.

Charlatans qualifies as a successful comeback after fourteen years away from the scene. The Defaced spoil nothing of their modest legacy and might even enhance it after the dust settles on this record.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 04/03/2022

Record Label: ViciSolum Productions

Standout tracks: Bleeding Ore, Celestial Display, Son of the Sun

Suggested Further Listening: Testament – Low (1994), Psychotic Waltz – The God-Shaped Void (2020), Nevermore – Dreaming Neon Black (1999)