
To be a rock band these days is a risky venture. In the absence of a monoculture to filter rock to the masses through the same narrow media, its artists struggle to make themselves heard or appear relevant to the TikTok generation. Yes, there is the oversupply of generic post-grunge bands (or “butt rock”, as Americans calls it) and enough parents who lived through Nirvana and Pearl Jam to pass on their musical tastes to their children, but the genre has no edge to it these days. Kids in the 2010s are more likely to learn how to chug an eight-string guitar than strum a six-string neck in imitation of Nickelback or 3 Doors Down. Shun are once such band that start with one hand tied behind their backs even though they coat their songs in heavy distortion.
Dismantle is the North Carolina quartet’s follow up to their 2021 self-titled debut, and it stays clear of the faceless post-grunge nonsense that passes for rock these days. Opener, ‘Blind Eye’, starts with a late afternoon chord-picking passage in search of a breeze before Matt Whitehead steps on the distortion pedal. He digs deep into his stomach to unleash his voice as if finding the most anxious projection of words he can muster in a melody. The guitar motif from the intro is the one constant in the song. You think this will be a straightforward rock affair, but the band strip things back after the second chorus rather than continue at an uninterrupted tempo.
The most interesting thing about rock is the way the singers approach their vocal lines. Unlike metal, they have more room to be creative with melodic phrasing and a multitude of emotions beyond rage. A softer tenor voice spearheads the guitars in ‘Aviator’. Here, two guitar channels talk to each other in different frequencies. The drop-tuned strumming in maximum amp gain lends plenty of weight to this music. ‘Drawing Names’ asks you to envisage mid-90s day Soundgarden under the influence of U2. It’s easy to mistake the mid-tempo pulse for lethargy, but the song arrangements stand up to scrutiny. Listen how Whitehead allows the droning chords to hang in the mix so they can form a parenthesis around his words.
But why does rock music find it so hard to enthral the listener? ‘NRNS’ is Queens of the Stone Age on steroids, yet it has little to merit a second listen. Likewise, ‘The Getaway’ is high tempo melodic rock with a husky strain to it and grungy chord formations in the chorus. Again, it does nothing wrong, but can you remember it after three listens?
Only two efforts on side B raise more than an eyebrow. You can feel your top lip protruding and shoulders bobbing to the opening bass groove in ‘You’re the Sea’. This song is gritty. Is this how a mechanic feels after a long day under the hood of various cars? Closing track, ‘Interstellar’, is just as enlivening. The slow grinding thud of the bass would not be out of place on the new Sumac album. Whitehead approaches his lines like Kurt Cobain’s vocal performance in ‘Something in the Way’. More compositions like this would help this album transcend beyond a sincere but comfortable musical landscape.
Unfortunately, too much of this record causes your head to droop. It’s rare to say these words, but this music needs more angst.
Verdict


Release Date: 19/07/2024
Record Label: Small Stone Records
Standout track: Horses, Drawing Names, You’re the Sea
Suggested Further Listening: Queens of the Stone Age – Queens of the Stone Age (1998), Soundgarden – King Animal (2011), Of Concrete Gods – HurtpeopleHurtPeople (2024)
