She Must Burn – Umbra Mortis


London blackened deathcore extremists, She Must Burn, have had an eventful eight years since their formation in 2014. Cradle of Filth handpicked them as support for their 2015 Inquisitional Torture tour, and they played the United States with Lorna Shore, Rings of Saturn and Carnifex in 2017 to promote their debut album. The band’s original keyboardist and soprano, Aimy Miller, left not long after the release of Grimoire, with founding members, Joe Sinclair, Jonny Davies and Daniel Ristic departing over the next few years. Now, they return with their sophomore effort with four new members and only James Threadwell (guitar) and Frank Keating (bass) remaining from the original line up. This isn’t a makeover; this is advanced surgery to a band that once starred at Download and excited the metal press in the mid-2010s. The fact they still exist says a lot about the credence of their name, but have they squandered their moment in the spotlight?

All the focus in the metal world is on the new Lorna Shore album as the breakout success of 2022, and She Must Burn’s former touring partners deserve the acclaim. But it’s unfortunate that Umbra Mortis sees a release on the same day because this record demands wider publicity. New mezzo-soprano vocalist and keyboardist, Valis Volkova, adds an incandescent sparkle to the midnight splendour of the band’s aesthetic in the album’s introductory track, ‘Nine’. You might wonder if you’re in the presence of a thespian performer during her narration, and that’s because she trained at the Royal Northern College of Music and has a background in theatre. It makes the extreme metal assault of ‘The Rats in the Walls’ even more surprising and reminds you that new screamer-in-chief, Kyle Lamb, is just as powerful in his monstrous projections. The pig squeal mouth transgressions and blast beats ripple with the insanity of Strapping Young Lad and groove with the crunchy bite of Carnifex. Christ, this is more aggressive than a fox in a chicken coop. Listen how the breakdown grinds your skull like an automaton. You’ll cling to Volkova’s operatic moments of blinding light as if clawing your way out of a mineshaft. ‘Of Blood and Bone’ multiplies this by ten and adds even more into the orbit of chaos. Say hello to a black metal take on Kataklysm with a gothic waltz straight from Beetlejuice. Carach Angren’s booking agent should be on the phone to them as you read this review.

It’s unusual for a band to represent a perfect amalgamation of their former touring partners, but Cradle of Filth and Carnifex are the obvious comparisons on the title track and ‘Misery Eternal’. This is intense music with a relentless mission to hurl you against the wall like a hurricane of biblical proportions. You know Volkova’s sorrowful mezzo-soprano voice will grant a modicum of respite in every song, but she seldom takes the limelight away from Kyle Lamb, who masters the death metal gluttony voice with the same efficacy as his black metal shriek.

At the halfway point, you ask if this can get any better, and it doesn’t. That’s because the guitarists dilute their fretwork in a succession of conventional chug rhythms that the symphonic keyboards and rapid-fire vocals delight in swallowing up like hungry bears. You can’t fault the energy or purpose of ‘Souls Asunder’ or ‘The Serpent’, but the formula that illuminated the brilliance of the first four tracks loses its sheen in the last quarter. The band rely too much on the ferocious hiss of the vocals as another percussive element in the verse parts of ‘Misery Eternal’. They can thank Volkova for saving them from monotonous repetition with her radiant performance in the chorus.

‘Incantation’ is the standout song of side two, and it makes you feel like you’re among a live audience. You can breathe in the excitement of the concert hall and inhale the flames of the pyrotechnics like a spectator at a Rammstein show. Clearly, She Must Burn have no desire to compromise on the extremity of their music. It might have deathcore foundations, but this belongs on the same stage as Fleshgod Apocalypse and Shadow of Intent. All those classical musicians that graduate music college in Europe this year with thoughts of forming a symphonic metal band should hold off until they hear this record. This is how you inflame the melancholy of gothic metal and inject it with a murderous streak of black metal and drop-tuned deathcore syncopation.

It might be two songs short of an instant classic, but Umbra Mortis should serve as a warning to others – She Must Burn are back. The future of metal and the future of the band are not the same thing, but they could be if they keep a stable line-up and continue this trajectory.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 14/10/2022

Record Label: Grey Rock Music

Standout tracks: The Rats in the Walls, Of Blood and Bone, Incantation

Suggested Further Listening: Saphath – Ascension of the Dark Prophet (2022), Carnifex – World War X (2019), Shadow of Intent – Elegy (2022)