Secret Rule – UNiNVERSE


Italian symphonic metal unit, Secret Rule, are one of the hardest-working bands in the scene. Though formed in 2014, UNiNVERSE will be their seventh album and the fifth consecutive release since 2019. Covid-19 disrupted the output and livelihood of many artists, but Secret Rule found time to issue an album of covers when they realised that 2020’s Against LP would be a promotional write-off. They’ll have finished a November UK tour with German heavy metal titans, Rage, by the time you read this review. Are they an extraordinary exception to the music industry’s usual cycle of recording and touring or a slave to its grinding routines?

It’s clear that Secret Rule could not continue without charismatic soprano, Angela Di Vincenzo. As the face of the band, she’s also the voice that carries the music. This means guitarist, Andy Menario, has the difficult job of imposing his presence in a mix dominated by the powerful vocal melodies and heart-wrenching tribulations of his singer. To be fair, he does a good job and avoids most of the pitfalls that make goth metal and its symphonic offshoots such a bland listening experience. You might sigh when you hear the obligatory electronic beats and digital synths in the intro to opener, ‘Disorder’. But the dramatic orchestration of Di Vincenzo’s choir vocals will make you sit up. Menario follows it with a flamboyant pinch-harmonic riff for the metal faithful. Maybe this won’t be the second-rate Theatre of Tragedy pastiche you expect. Nobody told bassist, Nick Pedron, to remain in the background. He plucks away at his dangling strings like Billy Gould of Faith No More. Palm-muted guitar hooks bite in the gaps of the chorus like opportunistic spiders pouncing on inferior insects for their lunch. You can mosh to this, play air guitar, or hold an imaginary dagger to your heart. It’s your choice.

Of course, the chorus is the focal point of a Secret Rule song. Like Within Temptation and Delain before them, the Italians often rush to this part of the song as if scrambling for the exit door at the sound of a fire alarm. It works wonders in ‘Equilibrium’, which needs only two listens to reveal is emotional splendour. ‘Shards of Time’ is not quite as successful, perhaps because they see the stairway to the chorus and ignore the important steps that lead up to it. Menario seems to understand the detrimental impact of this and does his best to impose his heaviest and most expressive riffs of the album in these two compositions.

‘Gravity on Us’ is the first time they slip into an Evanescence plodder, but Di Vincenzo extricates them from mediocrity with heartfelt vocal heroics that stand out for the richness of their melodies as much as the anguish of their delivery. One wonders if Angela writes the vocal lines before she creates the lyrics. The title-track conjures images of a heroine tiptoeing in the forest snow of Narnia. How does she jump from the second rendition of the chorus into a higher octave? Here, the guitars and bass punch in and out with simple syncopated shapes that serve the song as effectively as scouring pads cleaning out the limescale on your bath taps. You’ll finish ‘I Am’ wondering which part is the chorus. They appear to unwrap it in the electronic intro with a dramatic orchestration of sound, yet the reoccurring anthemic sections throughout the song are different. Again, the loose bass guitar strings rumble the land like a tractor engine in first gear. Oceans of Slumber and Within Temptation would benefit from these types of low-end grooves to thicken their sound on future albums.

Only two things hold back the full potential of this album as an outlier in its genre. The guitar riffs leave an impression at the beginning of most songs, but you soon forget about them because of the formulaic song structures. Most tracks here strip out the guitars as the main instrument in the verse parts. The aim is to protect the power of Angela’s voice as the dominant feature in the music, but it reminds you of the predictable structures that bedevilled nu metal at the beginning of the century.

Likewise, starting each song with fifteen seconds of celestial synths and sampled beats becomes irksome when you realise that none of these intros will expand into anything more meaningful. ‘From Null to Life’ is guilty of this. Why not take a chance and follow the synths into new paradigms to see if Angela’s voice can co-exist with them?

UNiNVERSE is not the innocuous arena-hungry metal that the European festival crowds love, and the metal elitists love to hate, and it can take credit for trying to steer a tired genre in new directions. No other symphonic metal band puts as much thought into the monstrous bass grooves, nor do the guitarists invest as much time in surviving an uphill battle which their stupendous singer will always win.

Heavy metal is entertainment. Secret Rule remember this fundamental truth. They entertain for the right reasons.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 24/11/2023

Record Label: Lucky Bob Records / SPV

Standout tracks: Equilibrium; UNiNVERSE; I Am

Suggested Further Listening: Delain – April Rain (2009), Within Temptation – The Unforgiving (2011), Oceans of Slumber – The Banished Heart (2018)