Orthodox – A Door Left Open


Nashville straight edge crew, Orthodox, arrive at album number four with Century Media behind them and a headlining US tour ahead. They also have a new member in the ranks to add guitar solos to their hardcore assault. We should be excited, and we were for their last record. Scream Blast Repeat enjoyed 2022’s Learning to Dissolve, noting that it ‘does the business of psyching you up to face the world outside.’ So, why does this record feel more like a drag than a drug?

Rolling guitar chords and white-hot rage need only ten seconds in opener, ‘Can You Save Me?’, to establish their first chug of the bottom strings. But Orthodox have no interest in giving you the djun-djun-djun rhythms without some variation in tempo from the drums. This lends the music a more chaotic nature, like Vein.fm under the guidance of a beatdown band from the tough-guy scene. When they embrace the down-picking riffs, they do it as if creating a metal equivalent of the Jaws theme tune without the tempo acceleration and dynamic build-up (see ‘Dread Weight’).

Orthodox might cite nu metal bands as formative influences, but the likes of ‘Body Chalk’ and ‘Godless Grace’ are hardcore in the mould of Code Orange minus the industrial influences. ‘Blend in with the Weak’ presents the first sign of a Prong riff with natural harmonic fretting and a steady 4/4 pocket groove. They use gang vocals to great effect here, but the structure of this song is more predictable than the previous three tracks. And this is where the first signs of weakness appear. Does every writing session start with the guitarist chugging on his strings to form the genesis of a new idea? It seems written with the audience in mind. Clearly, Orthodox want you to banish your demons in the pit.

You can always spoil a good thing with too much excess, and that’s what happens to the quality of the action for much of A Door Left Open. There are too many palm-muted intervals and not enough variations in rhythm and technique. The advice from this reviewer: take a break after side A and come back to side B with an open mind. That way, ‘Sacred Place’ will be more of a blast after a brief interregnum in the listening flow. Observe how the drummer lives on the edge of the groove in this song. The guitarists slash at their strings with the same brutal simplicity as Dino Cazares (Fear Factory) until 01:20. Then, they deconstruct their main riff and reintroduce it with a new rhythmic pulse as Easterling repeats, “There’s no room left for me.” Imagine Jesus Piece covering Korn.

It’s true that nu metal would’ve been more tolerable if it was as mean and as muscular as ‘One Less Body’. The dark disenchantment of Korn’s debut penetrates through the hardcore exterior here until a powerful vocal uplift from Mastodon’s Brann Dailor jerks it in a different direction. You can pick out some material worthy of merit on this LP if you look hard enough. ‘Step Inside’ is one of the few times when the two axemen diverge from each other with one landing the staccato palm-mutes and the other digging into the strings in fast alt-picking motion. It’s good to hear the bass carry the transition parts at the end as the shrills of feedback bleed from the amps.

‘The impact of the testosterone adrenaline starts to wane after seven songs. You wonder if the abundance of meathead riffs will run dry,’ said Scream Blast Repeat of their 2022 album. And the same applies here. The stubborn caveman shapes of the guitar start to tire again in the last quarter. At least they don’t pile on the tedium with overprocessed double-kick beats like the deathcore bands, but Orthodox don’t leave their comfort zone, either.

Thirty-two minutes feel like fifty-two on this record, although Orthodox produce a brief moment of blissful guitar melody at the midway point of closing track, ‘Will You Hate Me?’. Likewise, the spoken word narrative offers a rare change of timbre, but this is a bleak album of little variation or repeat listening value.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 06/06/2025

Record Label: Century Media

Standout tracks: Sacred Place; Body Chalk; Step Inside

Suggested Further Listening: Jesus Piece – Only Self (2018), Korn – Take a Look in the Mirror (2003), Creak – Depth Perception (2023)