Of Virtue – Sinner EP


A question that remains intangible is how the merger of metal and hardcore in the late 1990s ended up being the one genre in heavy music that would be the most susceptible to pop trends. The original metalcore artists combined Slayer and Cro-Mags, but now their modern offspring have a strong penchant for R&B and a regrettable nostalgia for nu metal. Nowhere is this more apparent than in the latest record from Michigan’s Of Virtue, a group that take the cancerous influences of Bring Me the Horizon and Linkin Park and package them into their own attempts to expand the colour palette of contemporary metal. Sometimes, there are limits in place for a reason, and this EP is one of those occasions.

You can count on one hand the number of bands that are not Faith No More who can mix the charm of pop and the brutality of metal into a successful formula. Most artists undertaking this inadvisable experiment forget the missing ingredients of humour and subversion, and Of Virtue are no different to those that came and failed before them. Opener, ‘Hypocrite’, throbs along on a nu metal bounce riff and incorporates the discordant industrial samples that Korn used in their imperial phase at the beginning of this century. There’s no shame if this reminds you of the MTV2 era and forces you to emit a smile. You might even enjoy the anthemic chorus and hum the melody in your head. The upcoming Architects album promises something similar later this year but with heavier riffs. It’s not unlistenable.

‘Sinner’ on the other hand, is the definition of an iconoclastic metal song. Those of you that hate the shallow R&B vocal lines that dominate modern radio and proliferate on TikTok will despise this song. The annoying pitch correction effect of the auto-tuner should offend your listening tastes, but this is a confident pop song with perfect vocal delivery and a marvellous bridge that could be straight from an Usher track. If only they didn’t spoil it with a throwaway Bring Me the Horizon chorus, like a boy band aiming their dry tears at an audience of teenage girls.

With talent for hooks and harmonies, you must ask why Of Virtue need to stay within the confines of their polished metalcore origins. ‘Cold Blooded’ mixes Evanescence with the urgency of Blind Channel and almost succeeds in keeping you interested with its heavy dose of drop-tuned guitar contortions. But, of course, they cannot resist the temptation to imitate the bland pop-metal of Linkin Park on closing track, ‘Echoes’, which is less fun than watching a tree grow in your neighbour’s garden. Who remembers when every nu metal song started with lo-fi electronica beats? Of Virtue do, and they have no shame in re-treading this cliché when you should be enjoying the type of melancholy electronic pop that Greg Puciato likes to embrace in his work with The Black Queen. Take out the dull chorus and this song has more to offer than it seems on first listen, but the exterior gives you no reason to approach it in a favourable mood.

An open mind is healthy, but a closed one will be the default position here. Of Virtue’s music is formulaic, and their melancholy mood speaks of a band that have had too much sex in the past – not too little. Nobody can doubt the talent they have for writing catchy songs with multi-layered harmonies, but they do nothing to advance the cause of metalcore when nu metal and R&B are their core elements.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 12/08/2022

Record Label: Arising Empire

Standout tracks: Hypocrite, Sinner

Suggested Further Listening: Imminence – Heaven in Hiding (2021), The Oklahoma Kid – Tangerine Tragic (2022), Venues – Solace (2021)