
Motherless is a collective of Chicago veterans that can claim current members of The Atlas Moth and ex-members of Chrome Waves and Thurston Moore’s black metal supergroup, Twilight. Though only formed in 2023, they landed a deal with Prosthetic Records in no time and now present their debut album with the Chicago underground looking on in curiosity. The rest of us might also have a thing or two to say about it.
You’ll understand within ten seconds of ‘Reptile Dysfunction’ that this is sludge metal from the hardcore school. Rough vocal screams and head-banging drums collide with shapeless guitars to create a hopeless mess supercharged by loud basslines. Stavros Giannopoulos shows a surprise penchant for the black metal shrieks when expelling the agony from his body. Fortunately, the riffing is much more severe in its structuring and execution in ‘Abrupt Violence’, like Celtic Frost’s comeback LP from 2006.
Drummer, Gary Naples, sees the release of two albums this month, his other being the twelfth offering from death-doom legends, Novembers Doom. This is nothing like his more famous band. Stand back when these guys have the grit between their teeth. This is punk with the thick distortion of metal and its low tunings to match. Somehow, Giannopoulos manages to play rhythm guitar while exploding with vitriolic rage. You wonder how many ulcers he developed in his throat after barking into the microphone with such misanthropy. By contrast, ‘Darling, You Don’t Look Well’ permeates through the walls like a cinematic suspense scene in the intro as a high-frequency drone and crunchy guitars lead into another salvo of psychopathic aggression. Imagine the Melvins given a makeover by the trauma-expelling turbulence of The Ocean. Here, screams linger, snares clatter, chords vibrate out of key, bass notes throb under the heat. It’s heavier than the workload of a junior barrister.
The only irksome aspect of this music is the deadpan screaming, which often sounds like a man who takes pride in being out of tune. Likewise, the thread of chords in the main riff to ‘Weaponized Goodwill’ is innocuous underneath the overflow of electricity. Only when the axemen scrape their plectrums on the bridge of their instruments in a chugging rhythm can you get into the groove.
The most subtle quality of the guitarwork lies in the love of discordant interval shapes. Everybody does this in metal these days, to the point where it’s now the rule rather than the exception. You wouldn’t argue if somebody insisted this album was an example of blackened sludge metal, even if the number of micro-genres is absurd in today’s musical eco-system. Yet it feels like we’ve stumbled on a lost recording from Sepultura’s Roots sessions with Ross Robinson in the intro to ‘Insect Politics’. The spiteful vocal abrasions differ from the drop-B sound of the Brazilians from this period, and an extra layering of atmospheric guitars offers a different flavour. But there’s no denying the Korn–Slipknot theatrics in the outro, where you imagine Stavros Giannopoulos pulling the sideways head pose as he breathes into the microphone in a threatening voice.
Motherless are most comfortable at the point where the pressure cooker is seconds away from 120°C. Closing track, ‘The New Romance’, is the most hardcore of all their efforts with a pulverising round of d-beats underpinning it. Yet you could put this on the same stage as any Swedish melodeath band if you zoom in on the hard rocking guitar parts and finger-tapping flamboyance. Clearly, there are some good ideas underneath the rubble of this music, but they don’t always come into fruition.
Verdict


Release Date: 19/09/2025
Record Label: Prosthetic Records (MNRK Records)
Standout track: Abrupt Violence; Darling, You Don’t Look Well; Christian Math
Suggested Further Listening: Elder Devil – Everything Worth Loving (2023), Culled – Psycles (2024), Row of Ashes – Tide into Ruin (2025)
