God Dethroned – The Judas Paradox


Dutch extreme metal unit, God Dethroned, are important enough to have a Wikipedia page. Though Henri Sattler (guitars/vocals) is the only surviving member from their 1991 demo, they’ve had fifteen musicians pass through their ranks over the years, including ex members of Pestilence, Epica and Aborted. Metal Blade released their last ten albums, but they now return with Reigning Phoenix Music as their label support for the twelfth LP of their career. Is there still an audience for them outside of the Netherlands, where the band are legends?

God Dethroned may be a revolving cast of musicians assembled by Henri Sattler, but they sound re-energised on The Judas Paradox, like a band with something to prove. A sauntering guitar arpeggio vibrates in the intro to the opening title-track as if waiting for a drum beat to give it substance. The clashing notes in the intervals resemble dirty puddles in musical form. Observe how a second guitar adds a melody to the chorus with simple phrasing on the higher reaches of the fretboard. This music is discordant enough to give you a cold, yet the anguished voice of Henri Sattler cries with pain and makes your eyebrows expand. Listen to the monkish backing vocals in support – this is how you write a grief-stricken song in a dark and challenging format. Perhaps the most impressive feature is the way it creates empathy in the listener.

You can detect a restless longing for glory in the beginning of ‘Rat Kingdom’ as Frank Schilperoort works through the tom drums, and the guitars build up to a frenetic pace. Now we’re in clear black metal territory with fast tremolo picking and demonic vocals. Here, God Dethroned show how black metal’s most underrated aspect is its ability to extract sorrow and melancholy from aggressive music. But it’s an agitated sorrow that can manifest into a violent desire for the individual to transcend humanity and become the Übermensch. By contrast, ‘The Hanged Man’ thrives on an exquisite detonation of double-kick drums and low-end death metal riffing. Here, we get the best of black and death metal in one song. The production is raw but clear in its separation of the instruments. A mood of disenchantment breaks through the amp distortion, even during the more flamboyant lead guitar parts. Is this music for a mature audience? Absolutely, yes, but it needs no bullshit warnings such as “listener discretion advised”.

For much of this album, you feel like you’re five years into an ascetic life in a monastery where you’ve experienced not one day of central heating or hot water. But you know your body can take it because your mind is strong. Listen to the blast beats and melodic tremolo pickings in ‘Asmodeus’. The bass grunts underneath like a clogged-up sewage pipe. Clearly, God Dethroned are not afraid of melody, but they’re not subordinated to it, either. Their decision to avoid the plastic extreme metal overproduction of today is to their credit. All those European bands trying to write melodramatic gothic metal should listen to ‘Kashmir Princess’ (or any of the Tribulation discography) for ideas how to marry the two without diluting the latter. The snarl of Sattler’s throat-shredding voice leaves you with a misanthropic stare on your face.

It won’t win legions of new fans, but God Dethroned can be proud of their efforts here. They make sure to add variation to their repertoire of songs on The Judas Paradox. More importantly, they work hard to prevent a lapse into boredom. Paradise Lost are as inspirational on this LP as Satyricon or Behemoth. Listen to ‘Hubris Anorexia’, where the palm-muted riffs grind like rusty chainsaws capable of only fifty percent of their former velocity, yet the faster parts roar with the force of a Category Five hurricane. ‘Broken Bloodlines’ is just as menacing. Are you ready to be thrown into the sea by a nuclear earthquake? The axemen use their plectrums like blades cutting at the rope that binds a captive’s hands together.

God Dethroned have had an eventful (and turbulent) career, and album number twelve is good enough to avoid clichés of being their swansong. Surely, they’ve earned the credit for at least one more record after this effort.


Verdict


Release Date: 06/09/2024

Record Label: Reigning Phoenix Music

Standout track: The Judas Paradox; Asmodeus; Hubris Anorexia

Suggested Further Listening: Satyricon – Rebel Extravaganza (1999), Paradise Lost – The Plague Within (2015), LIVLØS – And Then There Were None (2021)