Gargoyl – Gargoyl


Now here is an album that should stand out among the pack. Featuring Dave Davidson from Revocation and Luke Roberts of Canadian progressive sludge outfit, Ayahuasca, Gargoyl are a super side project signed to Season of Mist. People are excited about the prospect of a genre-defying progressive record in a year that might well be defined by the imperious advance of prog metal as the most innovative of all sub-genres in 2020. We know to expect the unexpected and to marvel at the possibility of some exquisite musicianship. But is there more to Gargoyl than just musical sophistication?

You’ll need to check the album credits within twenty seconds of listening to acapella opener, ‘Truth of a Tyrant’, to see if Jerry Cantrell of Alice In Chains is making an appearance as guest vocalist. Surely, that cannot be a lost recording of Layne Staley on follow up track, ‘Plastic Nothing’? Is Cantrell contributing riffs and vocal harmonies on ‘Cursed Generation’ with William DuVall joining him at the mic? The fact we’re asking these questions on the first three songs represents a major problem. Taking inspiration from Alice In Chains is always a good idea but imitating their unique dual vocal harmony is a distraction when the influence turns to imitation. Which is a shame because the music is more Voivod than Seattle grunge.

The PR machine is calling Gargoyl progressive grunge but take out the Alice In Chains vocals and what we have is a mixture of jazz fusion guitar with the occasional foray into metal. It’s a formula that works on the excellent ‘Electrical Sickness’, which thrives on similar chord formations as Imperial Triumphant and the same soundscape as Voivod six-stringer, Dan ‘Chewy’ Mongrain. Now this is challenging music with an effervescent edge. On ‘Ophidian’ they give us a bubbling verse like Faith No More’s ‘Cone of Shame’ but with more interesting chords and female backing vocals. Dave Davidson’s chromatic solo is a delight to dissect and will go down well if/when the playthrough appears on YouTube. Some of the compositions are truly unique. Luke Roberts’ vocals on ‘Waltz Dystopia’ emancipate beyond the Alice In Chains worship and explore more of a Devin Townsend approach. Here the dirty bass grooves and jazz chords give way to a detour of technical thrash riffs. Once again, it’s a pleasure to narrow the eyes and prick up the ears at every intricate note and drum pattern.

But still the spectre of Layne Staley remains and absorbs your attention when you should be enjoying the elegant jazz fusion and metal. It’s rare this reviewer uses the term ‘derivative’, but this is the definition of imitating another artist with negative consequences. The staff at Scream Blast Repeat love Alice In Chains and Dave Davidson’s work in Revocation has much to admire but add in the length of this record and you begin to lose interest by track nine. We know what to expect on every song by the time we get to ‘Ambivalent I’ and even the mercurial saxophone on ‘Acid Crown’ is not enough to save this record.

It’s with a heavy heart that this reviewer removes his headphones and yawns. This is not a bad record and the level of musicianship is formidable. And yet Gargoyl remains a promising idea rather than a realisation. Where they go next will define the future of this band. Let’s hope they drop the Alice In Chains vocal pastiche and find their own voice on their sophomore effort.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 09/10/2020

Record Label: Season of Mist

Standout tracks: Electrical Sickness, Ophidian, Waltz Dystopia

Suggested Further Listening: Alice in Chains – Alice in Chains (1995), Imperial Triumphant – Alphaville (2020), Voivod – The Wake (2018)