
Canada is a vibrant hub for modern grindcore, and Fuck the Facts are its most notable export. Along with Rotten Sound, they keep the genre alive and push it forward. You could argue they evolved beyond the pure grindcore of their youth as early as 2003’s Backstabber Ettiquette and have been an experimental/progressive band with an extreme metal core ever since. As the first full-length in five years, Pleine Noirceur is a welcome return to the fold for one of the best outfits in the underground, but the final product might surprise a few long-time fans and raise an eyebrow among those new to the party.
Unlike 2015’s Desire Will Rot, this latest effort is more in tune with post-metal and post-hardcore with elements of noiserock underpinning the violent metallic fury of its creators. The grindcore is present in spirit but fans will notice one big change in the Fuck the Facts sound – they seem to have spent the last five years listening to black metal. The dissonant tremolo riffs and raw blast beats of ‘Doubt, Fear, Neglect,’ ‘Pleine Noirceur’ and closing track ‘_Cide’ pulsate with transcendent aggression and curdling screams. Singer/screamer, Mel Mongeon, has a distinctive higher-pitched hysteria like Knocked Loose vocalist, Bryan Garris, but with even more pain in her larynx. Strangely enough, it suits the black metal segues as much as the metallic hardcore of songs like ‘Sans Lumiere’.
To say this album embraces a multitude of genres in its experimentation is an understatement. Aside from ‘Ailleurs’ and ‘Sans Racines’, you’ll find little grindcore but other styles in abundance. ‘Aube’ touches upon doom metal and ‘An Ending’ is like a post-hardcore band using the guitar stylings of Shellac to lay on the Neurosis vibe. Nowhere is the new sound better personified than on ‘Everything I Love is Ending’, which thrives on a sludgy morass of downstroke intensity like the latest EP from Rae Amitay’s Errant project. It’s clear guitarist and founding member, Topon Das, studied the chord formations of Helmet’s Page Hamilton during the writing process of this record and paid attention to the more aggressive side of post-metal over the last five years. The death metal of the band’s mid-2000s period crops up on ‘Dropping Like Flies’, with the familiar Carcass machinations of Symphonies of Sickness rearing their head in the angular riffing. Yet close your eyes and this could just as easily be from the latest Tombs record.
Long-time fans will have one main concern: Is this still a heavy offering if the grindcore is no longer as prominent? You bet it is! Marc Bourgon’s bass lines are chunkier than a Japanese sumo wrestler and just as floor-shaking. Topon Das’s experimentation with more dissonant guitar melodies allows for a perfect equilibrium between the low end and higher noise frequencies, none more so than on ‘An Ending’, which contrasts well with Mongeon’s blood-coughing vocal spew. That bold claim of many bands that no two songs are the same is accurate here.
But if the willingness to incorporate a vast array of sounds makes for interesting listening, it also reminds you that it does not always make for supreme music. Two problems arise with this album. First, not one of the songs stands out as an exceptional composition, yet neither do any of the efforts fall below a standard definition of ‘good’. Second problem: the band’s technical sophistication is impressive but can also baffle the listener. The title-track and its predecessor, ‘Ailleurs’, have no structure. Whether that is a deliberate attempt to second-guess the listener is hard to say, but the same thing happens on the closing track, which ends in a maelstrom of washed out chords and black metal blasting. Again, you wonder how they manage to switch tempos with such ease but then struggle to recall much of the composition.
Pleine Noirceur will win many plaudits, yet it demands many listens before you can understand it. The ingenuity is somewhere among the sonic bludgeoning, but after five listens this reviewer laments that he still cannot find that magical ingredient. It’s sophisticated, it’s technical, it’s raw, it’s never dull… But it falls just short of a classic.
JVB
Verdict

Release Date: 20/11/2020
Record Label: Noise Salvation
Standout tracks: Pleine Noirceur, Dropping Like Flies, An Ending
Suggested Further Listening: Discordant Axis – The Inalienable Dreamless (2000), Amiensus – Abreaction (2020), Brutal Truth – Need to Control (1994)
