Damage SFP – Punished by the System


Finnish thrash metal trio, Damage SFP, produced two demos in the 1990s before splitting up in 1996. They reformed twenty-two years later and released their self-titled 2019 debut with songs composed in the 1991-1994 era. Now, they have the difficult task of writing new material for the first time in twenty-seven years, yet they approach their second album as if walking into the 1996-1998 era for misguided continuity. They retain their thrash metal foundations, but you’d be forgiven for thinking this is a major label punk record from the west coast of the United States.

Damage SFP’s decision to delve into the thrash metal lull that bedevilled the genre in 1996 is a baffling one. Out go the menacing aggression and edgy sonics; in their place come the catchy punk choruses for alternative radio. Instead, of Megadeth, they give us a tuneful “dad rock” coating of husky vocal lines and guitar melodies that belong on a Pennywise album. There’s nothing wrong with the energy or musicianship. Opener, ‘Betrayal in Your Eyes’, rips through the speakers like Slayer in the Divine Intervention era with an unusual drum groove. The muscular basslines pulsate underneath the distortion like scurrying rats in a drainpipe. Jarkko Nikkilä’s vocals pack the right amount of punch, but it’s debatable whether they suit the music. Here he sounds like Tim Armstrong of Rancid doing a James Hetfield impression from the Garage Inc. days. ‘Exiled from Paradise’ offers the same paradox. It sounds like watered down crossover-thrash aimed at rock radio in the pre-Napster epoch.

Thrash metal loses its purpose when it abandons its sense of reckless danger. The guitars in ‘Face Your Demons’ operate in an Anthrax/Nuclear Assault ferocity, but the manicured edges of the song’s pop structure place it in that awful 1998-99 period when all things heavy metal experienced a dreadful decline in pop culture relevance. Modern metalcore bands would appreciate the chorus here, but that does nothing to enhance its reputation. ‘Punished by the System’ cannot decide if it should be melodic punk or speed metal. The chorus uplift spoils the momentum of the snarling verse parts, just like Therapy? when they acquired the habit of doing the same thing with their inventive noise-rock thrash in the immediate aftermath of their 1994 commercial peak.

Only on the excellent ‘Track, Load & Charge’ do we hear Damage SFP at their best. Here, the guitars bite with a mid-to-high range onslaught of rapid finger movements, and Nikkilä pulls the band away from the 1990s mainstream punk in favour of The Misfits. You can hear Megadeth’s iconic fretwork in the dynamics, just as you can detect Dave Mustaine’s influence in the intro to ‘The Greedy and the Selfish’, which would be another bumper thrash number if it didn’t slip into a husky rock chorus borrowed from 1998.

It’s always difficult to write new material after such a long time, but Damage SFP picked the wrong era in the wrong decade to relaunch their sound. They need to go back to their early thrash records and listen to the contemporary artists in the genre for a better idea how to reinvigorate their first love and retune it for the 2020s. Unless, they want to continue down the path of a safe rock band playing dangerous metallic riffs…

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 07/03/2023

Record Label: Samsara Records

Standout tracks: Betrayal in Your Eyes; Track, Load and Charge; The Greedy and Selfish

Suggested Further Listening: Therapy? – Semi-Detached (1998), Motörhead – Orgasmatron (1986), Metallica – Garage Inc. (1998)