Ithaca – They Fear Us


Inexplicable as it may sound, Ithaca’s 2019 debut slipped under the radar of this reviewer. As a band often mentioned in the same sentence as Employed to Serve and Svalbard, they should be a familiar name to all in the UK metallic hardcore scene. Their acerbic frontwoman, Djamila Boden Azzouz, is a passionate advocate for rooting out the clandestine power structures that maintain the rule of the middle-aged patriarchs who run our societies like puppet masters. A glance at the band’s cover art for their sophomore effort shows four moustachioed men dressed in immaculate white guarding their diva queen like protective older brothers. Last week’s interview with Kerrang! saw the group declare that they’re miles ahead of everyone else in originality and quality.

For once, the hype might be justified. Ithaca could be as important as Conjurer for the future of heavy music in the UK. You’ll leave yourself vulnerable if you go into this album expecting an art-school metal experiment. They Fear Us is heavier than the mountain of grain stocks building up in Odessa under Putin’s naval blockade. Listen to the crunchy guitar rotations scythe through your speakers like a hand-held threshing tool on opener, ‘In the Way’. Jesus Christ, this is violent! And yet Djamila switches between throat distortion and sugar pop lullabies with the same pathos as Courtney LaPlante. You might even rationalise it as a hardcore version of Spiritbox, which, of course, it’s not. ‘The Future Says Thank You’ is technical metal of the highest proficiency. Between the Buried and Me write riffs like these – complex, heavy on the chugs, respectful of all frets on the guitar neck. Ithaca play London’s Boston Music Room in August with Pupil Slicer in support. Can you imagine the bloodbath this will cause among the band’s eclectic audience? You’ll understand why Djamila has a tattoo of Converge’s iconic Jane Doe album on her thigh when you recover from the pounding.

The term “riff lord” and hardcore seldom belong in the same sentence, but the imagination and innovation of style in Sam Chetan-Welsh and Will Sweet’s playing will pique the attention of the thrash metal acolytes as much as the prog nerds. The combination of raw belting vocals and crispy palm-muted rhythms works wonders on the title track. Machine Head’s new album will be a corker if it produces the same standard of drop-tuned riffing, just as the members of Knocked Loose will applaud the brutality of the breakdown. This is how you combine inhuman ferocity with a sorrowful chorus of heartache and regret. You can see why they draw comparisons to Rolo Tomassi, but the introverted 90s filth pop of Curve might be a better reference. “You think we’re lightyears away/ You think we’re decades/ You think you’ve made your escape/ But we’re catching up again,” screams Djamila in a vengeful mood.

Music as urgent as this can create the illusion of invincibility, but you’ll find a fragile serenity underneath the bone-crushing violence and intricate guitar embroidery. It’s true that ‘Cremation Party’ is hardcore for the extreme metal crowd and will keep the gatekeepers happy. Yet the bludgeoning brutality of ‘Camera Eats First’ refuses to stay in one lane and resets to a luscious dream pop contemplation just when you can feel the veins throbbing in your temple. Ithaca have one foot in the prog metal door whether they like it or not. How else do you explain the mellifluous guitar melodies of ‘You Should Have Gone Back’? The soothing chords are like snowdrops in the way they radiate a rare moment of genuine solitude away from the noise and pollution of city life. One moment you’re in the sweet felicity of a peaceful utopia, but the next feels like a fracture between the forces of light and dark.

You know you’ve experienced something unique at the end of closing track, ‘Hold, Be Held’. How did we go from the savagery of metallic hardcore to the cascading beauty of Cocteau Twins and the sophisticated melodies of Tears for Fears? The breadth of imagination will leave you in awe. Ithaca are the real deal, and this is a magnificent work of art.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 29/07/2022

Record Label: Hassle Records

Standout tracks: The Future Says Thank You; They Fear Us; Number Five

Suggested Further Listening: Rolo Tomassi – Where Myth Becomes Memory (2022), Knocked Loose – A Different Shade of Blue (2019), Spiritbox – Spiritbox (2017)