
The duo behind All Are to Return are as anonymous as Carlos the Jackal. We know nothing about their identities or nationalities or previous musical output. Year zero is where they begin, and it’s the year zero of Pol Pot and the atrocities of Tuol Sleng. Like the former Cambodian dictator’s notorious dungeon of Phnom Penh, the human sounds of this EP writhe in agony and pain amidst dissonant torture instruments.
AATR II continues in the same industrial-noise fashion as the band’s debut self-titled EP from 2020, only this time the songs are longer and the harrowing vocal howls even more impenetrable in the mix. Opener, ‘Carceri’, broods with an extended intro of dark ambient drones and violent malfunction effects like electric cables snapping under the weight of industrial bolt cutters. Imagine the diabolical fear creeping through the engine of a Gridfailure track with bass incursions doubling up as percussion. It’s somewhat surprising when they rupture this unease at the two-minute mark with a sultry drum beat reminiscent of ‘The Wretched’ by Nine Inch Nails. Like Trent Reznor’s lyrical predicament of being ‘stuck in this hole with the shit and the piss’, All Are to Return are in the same boat, only they don’t try to dig their way out with anything resembling a chorus. This is the sound of horror – of abject terror and trauma screamed through the gullet of a man beyond rational capabilities.
The band claim to explore experimental doom music, but this reviewer hears none of this in either of the band’s EPs to date. ‘Surveiller et Punir’ is arbitrary noise rock backed up by droning keyboards and unsettling background screams. Five minutes of formless audio vandalism gives way to a creeping volume swell after five minutes to bring in an industrial beat at the end. It’s a cinematic climax that holds your attention like a snuff film – you can’t turn away. ‘Classified’ is the same type of vicious noise rock dissonance with the punishing self-hatred of the early Swans records.
The fear of sleepwalking into a dystopia is as common as the modern anxiety of life imitating art, and All Are to Return are happy to be the agitators of this message. This music wants to soundtrack the last days of societal collapse before we start murdering one another and eating the corpses of dead children. There’s no fun to be had here – that would cheapen the artistic experience. ‘Postscript on the Societies of Control’ rotates around a loop of ambient pedals and imposing bass notes and moves towards the dominance of an electronic kick drum. ‘De Profundis’ is what Joy Division would have sounded like if Ian Curtis remained alive for one more album and continued to explore ritualistic drum patterns and discordant guitars. The prospect of watching this spectacle live with the two members behind an anonymous screen sends shivers down the spine.
Beyond the harsh noise and masochistic pleasure, All Are to Return show signs of evolution on AATR II. Gone are the spazzy punk screams and spiteful glitches. In are the longer form cinematic pieces and excruciating vocal alleviations. What will they have in store for AATR III?
JVB
Verdict

Release Date: 26/11/2021
Record Label: Tartarus Records
Standout tracks: Carceri, Surveiller et Punir, De Profundis
Suggested Further Listening: Scard – Rusted Lock (2020), Farer – Monad (2020), Gridfailure – Epicenter MMXX: Quarantine Instrumentals (2020)
