
Most of you will know Soen as a supergroup of extreme metal musicians led by ex-Opeth drummer, Martín López. Bass guru, Steve Di Giorgio (Death, Obituary, Sadus, Iced Earth, Testament, Autopsy), was also a founder member but departed after the band’s 2012 debut. Now on their fifth album, the Swedish quintet are masters of their profession and regular producers of quality material. But are they easing into a comfort zone on this latest studio effort?
There’s no doubt this band are experienced songwriters who can knock out a tune. Every musician in Soen could also be a studio producer and ghost-write for other artists on demand. Vocalist, Joel Ekelöf, mastered the rock voice decades ago and has all the techniques of a master vocal coach, while López needs no introduction on drums and brings a progressive influence on the songs. One listen to opener, ‘Lumerian’, is enough to confirm that we’re in for another sensational display of musicianship and intelligent craft. The awesome triplet attack from the guitars and drums at the beginning will get you gurning in no time before the distorted bass and melodious vocals take over. Ekelöf’s strong combination of head voice and throat yarling is what you want Paul Masvidal of Cynic to sound like when he takes to the mic stand.
Some critics expressed concerns that Soen were a bit too indebted to Tool in the past, but this is no longer an issue. If anything, ‘Deceiver’ and ‘Antagonist’ draw inspiration from Pain of Salvation and Katatonia rather than the LA legends. Indeed, Adam Jones has failed to produce an interesting riff since 2001 and would not be capable of an extravagant lick like the crunchy syncopated genius of ‘Monarch’. Now this is how you execute a chunky metal groove. The solo at 02:31 seconds is just as good and determined to make the fretboard weep in a crescendo of sweeping emotions.
‘Illusion’ continues the stadium feel with expressive pitch bends and a chorus designed for rock radio. Don’t be put off by this. Soen exude a sense of wisdom and hindsight in their music that most artists would kill for, especially among the metal bands that want to break out of their niche and into the pages of the trendy music publications. ‘Modesty’ is a stunning concoction of rhythmic drum and bass patterns that disguise the simplicity of the verse-chorus structure to the song. There’s a way to retain your integrity and sense of purpose if you’re aiming for exposure in Rolling Stone magazine, and Soen show how to do it.
Saying that, Imperial presents a couple of problems for the listener. Imagine if Metallica produced an album of eight songs all in the format and mood of ‘The Unforgiven’. Sometimes it feels like we’re listening to a major label metal band of the early 80s under pressure to produce a ballad for the masses. Yes, the choruses are strong and the musicianship exquisite, but the compositions are too formulaic to earn the ‘progressive metal’ epithet. Closing track, ‘Fortune’, is a wishy-washy rock number that tries too hard to be mature. It will do the job for those who like MOR rock, but few metalheads will give it the time of day.
We know every one of these numbers could be stripped down and played on a piano to reveal its true majesty, yet it also highlights the other main issue – the uncertainty whether to keep things metal or melodic rock. The riffs are monumental but often used at the beginning and post-chorus before things settle down into a more comfortable dynamic. This only frustrates the listener and dilutes the overall impact of the heavier moments of this record.
Of course, it’d be nonsensical to criticise Soen for their soulful song-writing skills. So much of this album is admirable. A few moments might underwhelm and lapse into pondering rock pastiche, but Imperial is worthy of your wallet and promises to get better with each listen.
JVB
Verdict

Release Date: 29/01/2021
Record Label: Silver Lining Music
Standout tracks: Lumerian, Monarch, Modesty
Suggested Further Listening: Katatonia – Viva Emptiness (2013), Godsticks – Emergence (2015), Opeth – Heritage (2011)
