Estranger – Aether Nether


English post-hardcore quartet, Estranger, take their cues from The Fall of Troy and The Mars Volta, but they add their own blend of progressive art rock to the mix. It means that annoying Americanised word “math” will lodge inside your head for much of their debut album, but there’s nothing annoying about this ambitious undertaking.

A despondent sway of guitar in opener, ‘The Dive’, evolves into an exciting thump of syncopated rhythms with a layer of sliding chords over the top. Here, Pete Radcliffe daydreams his way through the passages with a bright tenor voice as high register guitars negotiate with the bass and drums. Clearly, Estranger’s raison d’être is to find melodies in the mathematical equations, something they find easy – perhaps too easy. Yet they also have a severe aggressive side to their music when Steven Theobald gets in front of the microphone. You might think you’ve stumbled on the underrated art rock of Mansun in the crooning outro.

By contrast, growling low-end riffs get ‘Never Odd or Even’ underway before you can digest what’s happening. Repeat listens reveal a wonderful extended chorus of call-and-response vocals between Radcliffe and Theobald. The fretboard shapes are in danger of information overload, yet the imaginative vocal lines triumph in those moments when your brain starts to throb. At track three (see ‘Stonekeeper’), you’re already prepared for the group’s characteristic swerves into different musical tangents. These come in many forms, many of them intricate enough for piano, some of them loud enough to force a nosebleed. A thirty-second burst of aggression can often find its release in a rumination of lush guitars and jazz bass phrasing.

The dynamic shifts are volatile but never oppressive enough to lose your attention throughout this record. And with multi-harmony singing arrangements like these, Estranger go way beyond their contemporaries in post-hardcore. Radcliffe demonstrates an advanced falsetto technique in the verse parts of ‘Miser in the Mausoleum’. Here, he carries it over into a lingering sorrow for the chorus as Theobald sketches the outlines of a metallic riff and disguises it as prog rock experimentation. This song is a textbook example how to blend low and high register guitars into one wave of distortion.

Chromatic rhythms and finger-tapped patterns compete with screaming vocals in the wildest parts of this LP, but you wish they could add more of them. You’ll sense a restless energy struggling to express itself in ‘By Tanner’s Blade’ as Theobald ramps us his guitar in the brief transition moments. The fast palm-muted stabs will make your eyes expand, but the band move on to the next part before you can enjoy them. Likewise, ‘Wish for Wishes’ cannot decide if it should do your legs in like a ruthless gangster or help you like a grief counsellor. Chunky riffs collide with panic chords and indie rock melodies that could be from any album by The Strokes. The finale is a tangle of grungy math rock.

Yet few bands with this level of obsessive detail in their guitar interplay dare to pay this much attention to their vocal arrangements. ‘Ritual of Spheres’ is Radiohead as an edgy post-hardcore outfit. ‘Mirror Drinker’ is rock with a capital “R.” Sam Rance takes the spotlight for this effort, and the result is a bass-led affair with solipsistic vocal ruminations and layers of inventive chord phrasings engulfed in electricity. A vicious solo towards the end hits all the right notes in the scales and bends the strings with overzealous enthusiasm. It’s good enough to end a live set or open one.

“All I wanted was to build us a safe home in the forest,” laments Radcliffe in closing song, ‘Where the Acorns Grow’. The title reads like a short story, and the lyrics read like shorthand memoirs. Radcliffe shows here that sheer human will can force words into a melody based on the mind as much as the anatomical tools at his disposal. You’re never quite sure what this music is, but you know there’s a hidden beauty underneath the pulsating movements and sophisticated layers of electric guitar.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 11/07/2025

Record Label: Self-released

Standout tracks: Never Odd or Even; Miser in the Mausoleum; Ritual of Spheres

Suggested Further Listening: Mansun – Six (1998), The Fall of Troy – Manipulator (2007), Indifferent Engine – Speculative Fiction (2025)