Oceans of Slumber – Where Gods Fear to Speak


‘One cannot fault the song writing, but one can lament that Oceans of Slumber are no longer a metal band,’ said Scream Blast Repeat of the group’s 2022 record. ‘What they do on their next album could mark an irreversible divorce from the metal underground if they continue in this direction.’ They now present album number six as a reborn metal unit. Their prog roots are on full display, and Cammie Gilbert is even more emotive in her singing. Where Gods Fear to Speak is a sop to the old fanbase, yet it also feels like a new adventure for the Texans.

You know within thirty seconds of the opening title-track that this is a metal album when the distorted guitars palm-mute their way into the mix. Cammie Gilbert goes for an aggressive Alicia Keys-esque voice, but Semir Özerkan answers her call with a venomous death metal roar. The guitar tone is raspy and morbid, the drums eager to show off their technical prowess on the double-bass pedal. Hark how the section after the first chorus dares to rip through a black metal cloud of dissonance as Cammie continues to oscillate her voice with great melody. The last album had too many predictable verse-chorus songs – this is the complete opposite. It’s like drummer, Dobber Beverly, wanted to include as many sub-genres of metal in the mix as possible while retaining a doom metal outline.

They waste no time in demonstrating their metal credential at track two. You can hear how they composed ‘Run from the Light’ from guitar rather than piano. The switch between doom and death metal is impressive here in the way it manages the two with minimal friction, especially the vocal arrangements. Cammie has the voice of an angel shot down with appendicitis. This song goes berserk at 01:30 with a medley of death metal spasms. More metal singers should study Cammie Gilbert and observe how she navigates through her scales to make the vocal lines more imaginative. Oceans of Slumber know they must make a statement if they want to retain their metal fanbase, and they do it in style here with a distinct pathos anchored around the emotive singing.

A few soulful elements from 2022 remain, yet they only enhance the mood. ‘Don’t Come Back from Hell Empty Handed’ is the first chance for the band to explore a cleaner sound built around slow-motion drums and guitar arpeggios. Cammie Gilbert needs no invitation to relax into a vibrato-heavy technique. This is the crossover song for the casual metalhead and those unfamiliar with their back catalogue. Dobber Beverly forces blast beats into this anguish before the song resets to a luscious Tori Amos blend of cascading piano shapes and pretty contralto vocals. Part two of this affair starts from a dissonant chord progression and operates like a long release of tension fired by two unrelated peaks of aggression.

“All I ever wanted to be was somebody, somebody’s dream,” laments Cammie in ‘Wish’. This is another sensual piece of angelic singing with weighty guitars in support. Did the band agree that they would make this record much heavier than its predecessor and even more indulgent of Cammie Gilbert’s classical voice training? Listen how ‘Poem of Ecstasy’ transitions from rock to gory death-doom in the blink of an eye. The drama explodes like a high society ball that turns into a satanic orgy. How does Cammie Gilbert retain her composure during this spurt of extreme musical aggression? It’s like they gave her an assignment to write the lyrics and vocal melodies from the basic guitar chords and then filled in the musical gaps with as much heavy distortion as possible.

An album with every musician trying to outdo each other is seldom dull. But it can be a bit self-indulgent. Why include a cover of Chris Isaak’s poncy 1980s hit, ‘Wicked Game’, as the last track? And can Cammie complete even one sentence without flaunting her remarkable vibrato technique? She belts her way through ‘The Given Dream’ as if auditioning for a role in Destiny’s Child while a synthwave apocalypse brews in the background. The piano makes a comeback in the second half of this LP. Oceans of Slumber are comfortable in the Beauty and the Beast setting, and few artists do it with as much power. The suspenseful rock posturing threatens to derail into a bloodthirsty metal assault that never had a look in on 2022’s Starlight and Ash. “I’m longing for this place I call home,” cries Cammie. Maybe she’s found it again.

We should be grateful that Oceans of Slumber remember who they are on this recording. The mid-tempo death metal riffing of ‘Prayer’ lends it a morbid tone to contrast Cammie’s agitated contralto. Here, Semir Özerkan adds more menace with a throat-scarring roar and then switches styles to a baritone gothic voice like David Bowie lowered by two octaves. “I still don’t your name,” wails Cammie in an admirable push of voice that’s ambitious even by her standards.

They hinted that they might be moving away from metal. Instead, they move closer to their roots on Where Gods Fear to Speak. Welcome home, guys.


Verdict


Release Date: 13/09/2024

Record Label: Season of Mist

Standout tracks: Where Gods Fear to Speak; Run from the Light; Prayer

Suggested Further Listening: Depressed Mode – Decade of Silence (2022), Tori Amos – Under the Pink (1993), Inner Missing – Dead Language (2022)