
Did Stillborn invent gothic metal with their 1989 debut Necrospirituals? Gregor Mackintosh of Paradise Lost admits that this album influenced him as a musician, which is quite poignant coming from the man most cited as the pioneer of the sub-genre with Paradise Lost’s 1991 classic, Gothic. They were also doing things prior to Type O Negative’s arrival in 1991, to the extent that Roadrunner Records signed Stillborn for the release of their third album in 1992 (see State of Disconnection). Changing their name in 1996 to Colossus to accommodate ex-Candlemass legend, Messiah Marcolin, on vocals did much to bury the band’s legacy, as did splitting up after releasing two demos. Nonetheless, a triumphant return in 2017 with their first album in twenty-five years helped to resurrect the question of their place in the birth of gothic metal. The boys from Sweden are back, and they want to revisit the sound of their 1989 debut with their latest record.
Opener, ‘Neophyte’, provides doom metal riffs for the ultimate zombie impersonation with arms in front and legs straightened at the knees. Kari Hokkanen’s bass vocals are lower than the debris of the OceanGate submersible that imploded at the bottom of the Atlantic. The slow crunch of the syncopated guitars allows you to tap your foot as the Wagnerian horns punctuate the gaps. Like any gothic band worth their weight in ghouls, they repeat the chorus to the point of turning it into a catechism.
The chunky guitars and unpretentious drums are two outstanding features of this record. “You’re so scared, I know you’re feeling low / In the dark, I see you want to glow,” ponders Hokkanen in ‘Children of Darkness’ before the band open a monumental Candlemass riff. The Type O Negative comparisons are inevitable here if you overlook the impressive use of double-kick eighth notes in the chorus and the keyboard-generated horn section. This song is a good indication of the enduring influence of ‘Iron Man’ by Black Sabbath. ‘Katharsis’ is no different. Think Candlemass under the hex of Christian Death. Yet at no point do the guitars suffer from dilution, unlike modern gothic metal, which is often timid and given to devilish gestures that find no match in the watered-down music. Here, orchestral backing vocals emanate from the keyboard without drowning the doom metal guitars.
You can snarl the words of these songs as much as you can feel them pierce through your cold heart. Stillborn like to dwell in a morbid paradigm, yet they can also be uplifting in the way they chant their words like incantations. ‘Dead Black Woods’ is how gothic metal should sound – not quite tongue-in-cheek, not distracted by synths, and focused on providing a metal riff you can grasp with two hands. ‘Albino Flogged in Blue’ could be The Fields of the Nephilim with an extra layer of Paradise Lost leading it to the lyrical observation that “We can see the angels in the skies.” By contrast, ‘We Monkey’ reminds you that Stillborn are a metal band first and a goth band second. This song offers the best guitar interplay on the album with the instruments panned in each ear and chugging against each other. Listen how the drummer indulges them with a cautious beat befitting of a funeral march. The riffing could pass for a Helmet song from their golden era of innovation.
Perhaps the one thing that highlights the weaknesses in gothic rock music is the refusal to countenance any other song structure than the one that serves the chorus. ‘Abigail’ and closing track, ‘When the End Begins’, are guilty of being too predictable. Indeed, the title of the latter may explain why it does little to deviate away from track number one in search of a unique identity. Repeating the song title as the lyrics to the chorus is tedious.
Those that dismissed the controversial My Dying Bride album from 1998 (see 34.788%…Complete) will recognise the tone of Netherworlds, and it’s one that’s enthralling enough to engage you until the end. This music makes you want to fall to your knees and curse the sky. Ideally, you want to be experiencing it live in the hope that you might meet the eyes of a leather-clad goth woman in a corset who thinks that BDSM is a softcore pastime.
“The future fades away / I see the young ones lie down with empty eyes,” shudders Hokkanen in ‘Motherland’. His growl sounds like a man regretting his abstinence from the things he loves, yet a mood of intruding barbarism threatens to upend its anthemic pretensions, and that’s not a bad thing. There is much to admire here once you accept the simple song structures and mantras.
Verdict


Release Date: 28/06/2024
Record Label: Black Lodge Records
Standout tracks: Neophyte; Dead Black Woods, We Monkey
Suggested Further Listening: Type O Negative – The Origin of the Feces (1992), Deathwhite – Grey Everlasting (2022), In Vision – Manuscript (2023)
