Night Thieves – Polarity EP


London alt-metal unit, Night Thieves, released their debut EP in 2020 and followed it a year later with their sophomore effort, Spiral. The latter saw them work with Paul Visser of SBR favourites, Black Orchid Empire, and raised their profile in Kerrang! and Metal Hammer. It also gave them the confidence to approach Romesh Dodengoda (Fit for a funeral, Bring Me the Horizon) to produce their latest offering. He loved their new material and did not hesitate to book them into the studio. The result is Polarity, an EP, which – true to its name – harbours no ambiguities.

Night Thieves are a rock band for metalheads. In other words, the type of guitar-heavy quartet that take the tunings and techniques of contemporary metal and process them into catchy songs that the singer-songwriter fraternity can respect. Opener, ‘Collide’, starts with an eerie guitar arpeggio that pulls together the notes into dissonant intervals that create images of air traffic control screens with clashing dots. The effect indues a feeling of paranoia, yet the drums and bass find a groove with ease as Jess Moyle lays down her contralto voice the way an anti-hero lays down a challenge to an overconfident nemesis. It’s clear that the chorus is the anchor point of the song, and the one part that brings together all musicians in an agreement of purpose. Add in half-timing drums for this convergence, and you have a song that Radio One would enjoy introducing to their playlist. Unfortunately, the low-end riffs in the chorus ring out in a typical power chord display of grit when the melodies need to match the imagination of Moyle’s vocal lines. This song could be better.

There is no such problem with ‘The Way the Story Goes’. This is a clever arrangement when you drill down into it. Listen to the subtle offbeat in the opening riff before the tempo regroups around a descending strum of chords for Moyle to make herself heard. Rick Hunter-Burns’ bass takes over in the second verse, in a classic swap of instruments like Tool (listen to ‘H.’ from Aenema for an example of this technique). The high register guitar melody would not be out of place on Paradise Lost’s underrated One Second album from 1997. A sorrowful middle eight writhes with a latent angst before the staccato guitars intrude upon the introspection and wrestle their way back into the mix.

Perhaps the biggest surprise of this four-track EP is the strong showing on side B. ‘Through the Looking Glass’ glories in the heaviest riff on the record with a burrowing guitar rhythm that feels like an incapacitated soldier trying to claw his way out of a crater. Jess Moyle stays within a simple range for the first verse and then ascends to a higher octave for the bridge. This is how you write a chorus. See if you can erase it from your memory after one listen. Paul Andrew makes better use of his bottom two strings here to glide between the chords. That’s because there’s less reluctance to let the axe dominate. A double-jointed breakdown riff shows the band at their metallic best and works a treat to navigate back to the chorus for the obligatory double rendition. No wonder Metal Hammer had it as one of their songs of the week upon release in January.

No songs extend beyond four minutes on Polarity. That’s unusual for a metal band (except for grindcore). This is where the music will appeal to a rock audience. Closing track, ‘Walkaway’, injects its groove metal stylings with an industrial flavouring, like 3Teeth. Moyle offers another misty-eyed vocal phrasing in the first verse. There’s nothing wrong with anchoring a song around a chorus if you can produce it to this high standard. It won’t win any prizes for unorthodoxy or risk-taking, but the note-perfect melodies will remind you of Birmingham prodigies, Insurgent.

Let’s hope that an album will expand on the band’s core strengths and embrace a more progressive approach without sacrificing the glorious anthemic moments. Their friends in Black Orchid Empire can help them accept this challenge – they’d be foolish not to pick up the phone to Paul Visser before their next record.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 19/01/2024

Record Label: Self-released

Standout track: Through the Looking Glass, Walkaway

Suggested Further Listening: Maziac – Permutations EP (2021), Tool – Opiate EP (1992), Insurgent – Sentient EP (2021)