Carnifex – Necromanteum


‘The days when metalcore fans used to boo them off stage and taunt them look even more absurd now they’re at the forefront of modern extreme metal. Few bands can match this level of brutality and keep you on the edge of your seat,’ said Scream Blast Repeat in our review of 2021’s Graveside Confessions. Album number eight continued the upward trajectory of the group and sharpened their credentials as the original blackened deathcore band. Fast forward two years, and Carnifex seem to be in paralysis. What should they do next – continue with the black metal approach or embrace death metal? The answer is both, and it’s as predictable as a general election outcome in Zimbabwe. How has the band that influenced Lorna Shore become a parody of them?

First, we must give credit where it’s due before we examine the flaws of this record. Vocalist, Scott Ian Lewis, is one of the finest projectors of hostile vocals in the business. Likewise, guitarist, Cory Arford, knows his way around a fretboard. There’s no doubt that 2019’s World War X is a bona fide classic of the blackened deathcore canon. Carnifex live and breathe metal music the way the late Trevor Strnad (The Black Dahlia Murder) did. And yet they manage to leave nothing memorable behind on Necromanteum despite having all the ingredients you want from an extreme metal record.

It’s not a hopeless affair, but this LP does little to excite the listener. Opener, ‘Torn in Two’, starts with panned guitar movements and drills down into the blast beats with ProTools working overtime. Scott Ian Lewis is in the mood to terrify with double-tracked vocals screaming at different pitches and painful grunts that sound like the aftermath of a bullet to the thigh. It doesn’t take long for the guitars to settle into the chugging action we expect in a typical deathcore outing. When will breakdown number one land? What about number two? At what point will the sweep-picking solo appear? Only the dramatic choir samples provide the chills to match the demonic vocals. The same thing happens on follow-up, ‘Death’s Forgotten Children’, which would have been groundbreaking in 2007 but sounds tired in 2023. In fairness, the chunky guitar shapes and syncopated rhythms are more interesting than the atonal wash of your typical atmospheric black metal band, but you’ll struggle to remember any of them on repeat listens.

Are Carnifex the symptom or the disease ripping through modern extreme metal? The audio engineering is lifeless and overproduced. Drum pedals mechanise like a digital watch spoiling a window display of Patek Philippe models. The title track is close to the unlistenable monotony of brutal death metal (BDM) and would be just as dull as its main adherents if it did not tiptoe in the cobwebs of gothic metal and allow the vocals to bring it to life like classic Cradle of Filth. How they can stretch out ‘Architect of Misanthropy’ beyond five minutes in a one-dimensional blast of maximum overdrive grind is beyond comprehension. When in doubt, throw everything into the mix and see what comes out – no wonder you can remember nothing of the action. ‘Bleed More’ is overproduced, overplayed, and over the top in its desperation to produce a malevolent piece of blackened death metal for the Lorna Shore crowd to absorb.

Instead of “how did we get here?”, we should look at it from another angle. What more can deathcore offer when it stops being deathcore and wants to be something else? Sometimes Carnifex appear to have the answer. ‘Crowned in Everblack’ is an admirable attempt to flush out the annoying incorporeal sonics of black metal in favour of a crunchy form of metallic riffing. The sinister keyboard accents ensure your attention remains rooted in the chaos rather than being alienated by it. They show on ‘How the Knife Gets Turned’ that their vision of an epic chorus can match the imagination with the outcome. Fans of the latest Immortal record will recognise the brilliance of the keyboard choirs in this song. If only they could produce more moments like this…

Necromanteum is the sound of a band tied to the comfort of the two-year album cycle with no ambition beyond taking it on tour and earning their crust. We all know that death metal does not pay the bills, but you’d expect Carnifex to fight for their living rather than treat it like a factory job.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 06/10/2023

Record Label: Nuclear Blast

Standout tracks: Torn in Two; Crowned in Everblack; How the Knife Gets Twisted

Suggested Further Listening: Crafting the Conspiracy – The Cosmic Key II (2020), Agathodaimon – The Seven (2022), Mental Cruelty – Zwielicht (2023)