
Revisiting an old lover like this during a pandemic is a conflicted feeling. Yes, there’s a lot of love there, but does the current situation make you view it with tainted glasses? Let’s find out.
The Coronavirus pandemic gave Underoath a creative way to push something new to fans, so, as part of the Observatory series, they opted to play three of their most powerful albums from start to finish. Lost in the Sound of Separation is the band’s 2008 studio effort and this a recording from a live stream of the record from July this year. As the first of the three golden works, it makes sense for the band to start with this one. It has a Metacritic score of 92 percent and received rave reviews on release.
Although, commercially, the golden era of Underoath is regarded as 2004-2010, the purist of fans will remember the outfit fronted by Dallas Taylor (now of Maylene and the Sons of Disaster), who had a remarkable singing voice and an incredible screaming range, too. It’s a remarkable achievement that they managed to replace Taylor and go in another direction and re-invent themselves in the process. This worked because Underoath post-2004 were almost a new band entirely. The one thing we’ve come to understand about the two incarnations is that the conflict between secular life and following the path of God is a difficult one.
Your initial feeling will be, “Wow! Was that really twelve years ago?”, when you put your headphones on. And that’s because this album has aged well. Putting the fact that it’s a live performance to one side, let’s not forget how raw and powerful this was back in the day. It was a good time for metal and hardcore with both scenes revelling in the euphoria of Dillinger Escape Plan’s seminal Ire Works album. This was just some more sugar on top of a bustling array of artists at the top of their game. Lost in the Sound followed on from Define the Great Line, which was a more poppy album, yet this record took Underoath to a whole new level of supremacy by turning the heaviness up to the highest notch.
What always distinguished Underoath was the transition between albums. Right from 1999’s Act of Depression, the band evolved with every new record in leaps and bounds. So, it’s interesting to see their transition post break-up to their latest reunion now we have something recorded again all these years later. If anything, it’s even tighter, which is rare after a long hiatus.
‘Breathing in a New Mentality’ still has a Beecher feel to it, the high pitch screaming in the intro as iconic as the chunky riffs. This time around it sounds more like grunting than screaming, surely a symptom of the band’s second transition. The intensity is frightening. Just sit back in your chair and marvel at the ferocity of the members on stage as they spin their heads in maniacal fashion and thrash their instruments with violent delight. Yet behind it all, the push and pull dynamics of Spencer Chamberlain and Aaron Gillespie’s vocals are still there. The track also reminds you how good the over-distorted electronic interludes were and how seldom they employed these Prodigy-like bass interludes at the time. Looking back, the band never shied away from experimental samples and synthesizers in the early years.
‘Anyone Can Dig a Hole but It Takes a Real Man to Call It Home’ still sounds as progressive yet even more precise. They’ve tweaked the screws and opted for a tighter fit. Yes, there will no doubt be zero crowd participation here, and there does feel like a bit of an echo in the studio, but that raw edginess is still there from the performance. ‘Emergency Broadcast… The End is Near’ utters familiar sentiments and imagines a post-apocalyptic world that is more realistic with each passing year. No wonder the band chose this album to re-record in 2020.
The final few songs on the record remind this reviewer how the album fizzles out and becomes forgettable towards the end, but that doesn’t necessarily mean the performances do that. ‘Desolate Earth… The End Is Here’ and ‘Too Bright to See, Too Loud to Hear’ force you to reassess your original judgement of the record as one that wanes in the latter stages. The energy is infectious with the momentum of the live instruments reaching an effervescence lacking in the originals.
It’s great to hear Underoath are back together recording new material and thinking of creative ways to reconnect with their fanbase. We salute this as a positive development for the metalcore scene, and it’s a reminder how important they are to the genre. The release of their next live playthrough cannot come soon enough.
OW
Verdict

Release Date: 06/11/2020
Record Label: Tooth & Nail Records
Standout tracks: Anyone Can Dig a Hole but It Takes a Real Man to Call It Home; A Fault Line, a Fault of Mine; Breathing in a New Mentality
Suggested Further Listening: Dillinger Escape Plan – Ire Works (2007), Beecher – His Autopsy, His Elegy (2005), Maylene and the Sons of Disaster – III (2009)
