
Michigan’s The Black Dahlia Murder are one of the five most influential Death Metal bands of the last decade. Their 2005 album, Miasma, is a classic of the Melodic Death Metal genre and has opened the door for many extreme bands to glimpse the wallets of a wider audience beyond the underground gatekeepers and true believers.
Now on their ninth outing, the band are at an awkward apex in their career where they have two choices – give the fans what they want or explore new territory. Unfortunately, they’ve opted for the former and churned out a record that has few faults but little in the way of innovation. Trevor Strnad’s vocals are as powerful as ever, Alan Cassidy’s drums pummel like Leatherface’s sewing machine, and the twin guitar attack never lets up in its virtuosity and precision. But there’s something safe and predictable here that diminishes the vigour of the Death Metal assault.
Verminous is not forgettable, but the question is whether it will warrant a listen this time next year. Yes, it has some standout songs that could easily fit on any of their previous albums. ‘Sunless Empire’ is a majestic thrash composition with mid-tempo downstrokes, harmonising guitars and a Marty Friedman shred piece. It’s the closest they come to an anthem in the chorus and will have you scowling at the sky with an air guitar pointing towards Jupiter. ‘The Leather Apron’s Scorn’ and ‘How Very Dead’ are similar in their charm with Megadeth riffs underpinning the trademark Melodic Death Metal of vintage At The Gates and Children of Bodom.
But the biggest weakness is the predictability. We’ve heard this type of music millions of times. As a sub-genre, Melodic Death Metal might be the most saturated in the Metal spectrum. Downtuned Slayer riffs with Iron Maiden guitar harmonies have been around since Carcass put out Heartwork in 1993. The Black Dahlia Murder were at the forefront of refining this formula in the mid-2000s, but now find themselves revisiting the same barren soil In Flames abandoned long ago.
It’s hardly a turkey, but Verminous will do little to win over new listeners looking for a contemporary piece of crushing Metal. The fanbase will not be disappointed, but its doubtful they’ll be intoxicated, either. If we’re being kind, we might say people will look back in a decade and identify this as the underrated album in the band’s impressive discography.
JVB
Verdict

Release Date: 17/04/2020
Record Label: Metal Blade
Standout tracks: Godlessly, Sunless Empire, How Very Dead
Suggested Further Listening: Carcass – Surgical Steel (2013), In Flames – Colony (1999), At The Gates – At War With Reality (2014)
