Primalfrost – Lost Elegies


Canadian shredder, Dean Paul Arnold, might be familiar if you watch Banger TV’s Lock Horns show or know of his lead guitar work as the live six-stringer for Belphegor. Besides guest work on Hate’s 2017 album, he also played with Vital Remains from 2015-2019 as their main axeman. The fact he’s only twenty-five is insulting. How can somebody be so accomplished at this stage of their career?

Lost Elegies is the third record in Arnold’s one-man solo project and the first since 2014’s Prosperous Visions. As you’d expect, the standard of musicianship is exquisite, but it also masks some weaknesses, namely the predictability of the music. Those of you that like melodic death metal and power metal will have nothing to complain about; those of you that like songs to do more than feed the ravenous shred machine will be less enamoured.

The record starts with enough promise to warrant an approving nod of the head. ‘Maelstrom’ does what its title suggests – it fires at you from all angles with a hurricane of competing notes, yet Arnold’s pipes are also worth a mention. His lungs are powerful and filled with bile as well as bite. The music might dwell in the heroic triumphalism of power metal, but the vocals do not. Listen to the surprise switch to neo-classical black metal at the three-minute mark. Where did that come from?

The problems start as early as track two. ‘Bringer of Immensity’ is flawless in its execution and not short of adrenaline, but you already know the song will rip through a million notes before the first chorus. This prepares you for overkill when you should be banishing all sluggish thoughts from your mind. ‘Nomad’ shows some self-awareness in the way it follows with a symphonic approach built around vintage Helloween/Blind Guardian guitar posturing. It’s also an outlier if you ever wondered how an orchestral breakdown riff should sound. Make no mistake, this is heavy stuff.

But allow your mind to wander, and there’s no coming back to the zone where Arnold wants you to be. ‘Stormbearer’ offers cascading folk guitars and abundant technical brilliance when the main riff kicks in, but the music is too clean. Virtuosity is the name of the game here rather than heinous brutality. It highlights the problem with melodic death metal – you hear nothing evil or menacing in the mix. The pre-programmed drums are splendid in the studio, but we all know they’ll be impossible to replicate in a live setting. Likewise, ‘Voyage into Ruin’ would be more effective if it ended at five minutes rather than carry on for another four. Here, Arnold reveals a talent for scoring a cinematic piece through the prism of metal – we should applaud him for his ambition on this song. Megadeth have a ready-made replacement if the lead guitar post becomes vacant in the future, although Arnold would be more suited to Amon Amarth.

Guitar nerds will love this album, but the majority of metalheads will lament the scarcity of original ideas. We need more songs like the excellent ‘As Embers Wane’, with its breath-taking folk guitar picking and female choir harmonies in the background. Your eyes will roll in the back of your head when you see the eleven-minute running time for the closing track, ‘Tenebrous Skies’. Okay, here comes a million notes, you might say in a moment of uncharacteristic cynicism. Yet this composition is far from predictable – give it a spin and let the whirlwind guitar rhythms sweep you off your feet.

Elegies will remind you of the last record from The Black Dahlia Murder. There’s nothing wrong with the music or its execution, but we’ve heard it too many times in the past. One wonders if Dean Arnold’s future belongs in the realm of progressive metal rather than the sterile settings of melodic death metal. Still, he remains a colossus regardless of the predictability on this outing.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 28/12/2021

Record Label: Self Released

Standout tracks: Maelstrom, Nomad, Solace Kingdom

Suggested Further Listening: Cathartic Demise – In Absence (2021), Demonstealer – And This Too Shall Pass (2020), Bloodmores – Too Close to the Sun (2021)