
Symphonic deathcore should be one of the most invigorating movements in modern metal. The dramatic orchestral hits, cement-mixer drums, and absurd throat transgressions are repugnant to most people and exhilarating to those that enjoy macabre music. Germany’s Mental Cruelty emerged on the scene in 2016 and signed to Unique Leader Records to serve their apprenticeship on the world’s most revered brutal death metal/slam label before Century Media scouted them last year. Perhaps the Sony-owned company eyed another opportunity to build on the momentum gained by Lorna Shore when they signed Mental Cruelty. Comparisons with the New Jersey titans are inevitable, but that would be a disservice to the German quintet. Blackened deathcore does not start and end with Will Ramos and crew.
Album number four has its moments of genuine intrigue, but it feels like the symphonic deathcore genre has already fallen into a homogenous formula after one listen to Zwielicht. The distant thunder and dark bass trombone effects of opener ‘Midtvinter’ remind you that metal can also be entertainment for the surround-sound cinema lovers who want drama with their blood sport. They get it on follow-up, ‘Obsessis a Daemonio’, which takes Anaal Nathrakh and Dimmu Borgir and repackages them in a grotesque death metal defilement. You can feel the wind and rain on your cape as you fall to your knees to recover that missing sense of self in the reflection of a puddle. Three gory breakdown rituals leave you wondering if disembowelment could be a lighter option. The pomp and drama of ‘Forgotten Kings’ imagines a chimera with bird-of-prey talents when it transitions from black metal to deathcore. Have you heard anything as predatory in the hierarchy of natural selection?
There’s no doubt Mental Cruelty deserve a place at the contemporary deathcore table on the evidence of Zwielicht. ‘Nordlys’ and ‘Mortal Shells’ are heavy enough to create a sandstorm in the deserts of New Mexico. The former starts with playful acoustic-guitar plucking and invites the distorted amps, drums, and voice to accent the chord changes in percussive rhythm. You can envisage a music video for the latter presented as an orchestral conductor dressed in a cadaver costume, guiding the movements of the band members. The sixty seconds of murderous breakdown posturing and strangulated throat vocals in the middle section will melt your face. Those of you whose sexual fantasy is to imagine your head underneath the guillotine blade will feel your eyes squint in ecstasy.
As we learned on the last Lorna Shore album, an excessive thirst for blood can have the opposite effect of what it intended. Zwielicht fails to shock after track six. You know all musicians will obliterate your brain with maximum velocity on every song, which makes the impact less severe once you can prepare for it. Should the countdown to the breakdown sections be the highlight of an album that aims to blaspheme against Christianity? There’s no need to engage with the lyrics on a serious basis. The usual remonstrations against the son of God and venerations of Satan are insipid enough to avoid offending.
Often, you’ll need to replay the tracks to establish where the guitars operate in the mix. No such problems exist with the keyboards or overproduced drums. New vocalist, Lukas Nicolai, deserves the highest of praise for his performance here. It’s not easy to step in when the previous singer lost his job over sexual misconduct allegations, but Nicolai brings a fierce malevolence to the microphone and energises the songs with his ferocity alone.
We said at the beginning that symphonic deathcore should be in the vanguard of contemporary metal. It isn’t, and that’s because it succumbed to predictability in the late 2010s. Nevertheless, Mental Cruelty show that it can still entertain.
JVB
Verdict


Release Date: 23/06/2023
Record Label: Century Media
Standout tracks: Obsessis a Daemonio, Nordlys, Mortal Shells
Suggested Further Listening: The Ember, The Ash – Fixation (2021), She Must Burn – Grimoire (2017), Brand of Sacrifice – Lifeblood (2021)
