Lifelost – Punitive Damnation


Lifelost is the solo project of Wormed frontman, J.L. ‘Phlegeton’ Rey. Those of you not familiar with the Spanish avant-garde death metallers might know him for his guest appearance on the last Imperial Triumphant album or for the cover art designs he produced for various extreme metal bands over the years. Punitive Damnation is his second Lifelost album following 2018’s Dialogues from Beyond, and it might also be the final proof we need that Phlegeton is probably one of the anonymous members of dissonant death metal kings, Altarage. This record evokes the atmospheric metallic dirge of the Bilbao collective but fails to reach the heights of their latest album.

We know anything with Phelegton’s involvement will be dark and obtuse, but this sophomore effort takes the atonal extremities of Portal and drowns them in a lo-fi black metal landscape. Opener, ‘Astral Construct’, starts with a creeping cloud of sinister horns and faint string bows until a sudden burst of blast beats and unmelodious guitar waves take over after forty seconds. It might catch you off guard if you’re unprepared, but you’ll spend most of the six minutes wondering if the guitars sound like an extractor fan on full power or a conventional instrument. Phlegeton’s vocals are barbaric and beguiling at the same time, but it’s difficult to recognise any chord changes in the guitar parts due to the deliberate hostility of the distortion.

Lifelost’s raison d’etre is to challenge your expectations of extreme metal and to strip away the extravagance and virtuoso musicianship associated with the genre. ‘Hidden Presence’ utilises a high-frequency tremolo pattern and mixes the dynamics with a fuzzy low-end overdrive in the verse parts. You’ll raise an eyebrow every so often, but this is when you realise the main problem with Punitive Damnation is the lack of material to distinguish it. Instead of marvelling at the transcendent sophistication of the atmospherics or conjuring images of a vortex sucking humanity into an abyss, you find yourself undertaking a microscopic and banal analysis of the instrumentation. The Bathory riff that sounds trapped in a catacomb on ‘Skulldrinker’ is the only thing that stands out. On ‘Winter Eye’, you might nod your head at the Darkthrone switch to a two-beat drum when you least expect it. ‘Lymbo’ includes a run of ritualistic tom drum rhythms at the beginning before the inevitable drone of dissonant chords and muffled blast beats enmesh it in yet another atonal wall of tuneless meandering.

Aggressive music must have a modicum of excitement, even if it’s an invigoration brought on by bloodlust. This record has nothing of the kind. Most songs simmer under the superficial heaviness of weak blast beats. ‘Miserwolf’ is less enthralling than listening to your refrigerator defrost over an interminable period of three hours. Only on closing track, ‘Time Terror’, does Phlegeton capture the essence of the first song with a nod to Satyricon and a magnificent exploration of bass-baritone harmonies. If only he could give us more of this enchantment.

Phlegeton has some good ideas and a clear vision for his musical cosmos, but the lack of variation smothers what could have been a strong album. Maybe the next Lifelost record will be the one that realises the dystopian sound of its creator in a way that does not alienate the listener.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 10/12/2021

Record Label: Onism Productions

Standout tracks: Astral Construct, Hidden Presence, Time Terror

Suggested Further Listening: Portal – Avow (2021), Altarage – Succumb (2021), Doodswens – Lichtvrees (2021)