Dream Theater – A View from the Top of the World


It’s something to take notice of any time a band as large or influential as Dream Theater, arguably the prog metal act, releases a new album. Sometimes divisive, always interesting, Dream Theater have created in A View from the Top of the World something refined that begs for closer examination.

The album starts strong with its lead single, ‘The Alien’, an almost ten-minute piece that was a clear choice for a standalone release. John Petrucci’s chugging guitar work is pleasing in its intricacy and punctuated by Mike Mangini’s drum fills. Here, the music wraps around you and presents you with vistas of colourful sounds. Then, two minutes in, James LaBrie’s vocals begin. This is where the album may lose some people. Over the thirty years that LaBrie has been performing with Dream Theater, his voice has been the main angle of criticism and is rightly considered an acquired taste. The man is a talented vocalist and has an excellent range, but when he begins singing on ‘The Alien’, the listener may find themselves thinking, “Oh, okay, this is what we’re doing now.” This doesn’t last long, however, as on reaching the chorus, the song begins playing to LaBrie’s strengths as a vocalist. Over the ten-minute running time, it allows the track to mature and for each of the band members to showcase their incredible musicianship.

The third cut, ‘Invisible Monster’, builds on this. The musicianship is, as always with Dream Theater, impressive, with the different musical themes fully explored in the kind of layered way that will have you reaching to play parts again to better appreciate them. This one has heavy shades of 1999’s Metropolis Pt. 2: Scenes from a Memory – one of their best albums – and they follow it with ‘Sleeping Giant’, which plays out like a jazzier take on 2007’s Systematic Chaos and demonstrates why Jordan Rudess is so deserving of his keyboard wizard persona.

Over the course of the seventy-minute run time, the band treat the listener to the full range of their iconic sound. There is shredding. There is soaring. Mike Mangini gives his best performance since replacing former drummer Mike Portnoy in 2010. A View from the Top of the World is a real exploration of what the band are capable of with their instruments.

As an aside that doesn’t affect the music at all, a special mention must be made of the album’s cover: a brightened, stock-photo-looking image of Kjeragbolten that does very little to sell the intricacies inside. It isn’t very imaginative and fails in the most important task of any metal album cover: to inspire tattoos.

In a way, this album cover fits quite well as not being imaginative is really the cardinal sin of A View from the Top of the World. It’s a safe album where, aside from the opening, the band members all play to their strengths and many of the songs harken back to past successes. This is a tough thing to criticise as their strengths are considerable and the similar parts to earlier works do sound good, very good, but long-term fans may feel like they’ve heard it all before. It’s not an LP that will change your mind about the band if you have no time for them, but it’s an excellent exploration of what makes Dream Theater great. It’s like a ‘Best of’ album but of new music. 

A View from the Top of the World may well be the Dream Theater-est Dream Theater album and would make an excellent starting point for anyone looking to see what all the fuss is about as well as serving as a celebration of the band’s musical abilities, even if it doesn’t push their skills as song writers.

Mark Stevens


Verdict


Release Date: 22/10/2021

Record Label: InsideOut Music

Standout tracks: Answering the Call, Invisible Monster, Awaken the Master

Suggested Further Listening: Transatlantic – The Whirlwind (2009), Dream Theater – Metropolis Pt. 2: Scenes from a Memory (1999), The Neal Morse Band – The Similitude of a Dream (2016)