
German unit, Downfall of Gaia, are one of the more creative interpreters of black metal, putting a firm emphasis on the Neurosis/Isis angle to their emotional meltdown where others would stick to their Darkthrone imitations. It’s common to hear d-beats as well as blast beats in their music, and they now present their sixth album with a well-defined sound that Metal Blade Records have supported since 2012. But is it a formula that needs changing to retain its dynamism?
Silhouettes of Disgust is high on emotion, and it brims with claustrophobic rage, but it feels predictable, like a reoccurring depression that will never be healed with anything other than medication. Opener, ‘Existence of Awe’, has all the ingredients of a post-black metal song – the clever synergy of atonal and melodic guitars, thick blast beats, psychopathic vocals, and moments of calm reflection to balance the inhumane aggression. The dropout to a distorted bassline at the three-minute mark shows great understanding of the cyclical nature of grief and recovery. It also allows them to reintroduce the high chest screams and furious drum snares at the climax as if scoring a film. The frenzied drum action in ‘The Whir of Flies’ is just as potent before the up-and-down emotions find a way to co-exist. Each moment of calm is like a luxury of five minutes away from the stress of modern life with its traffic jams, debt repayments, and oppressive identity politics.
None of the songs on this record sink into mediocrity, but they lose their efficacy as a collective whole. ‘While Bloodsprings Become Rivers’ is what Inter Arma would sound like if you asked them to write a black metal record. There’s no other way to describe this song other than a depressive torpor that locks you into a permanent state of anguish. That’s the purpose of Downfall of Gaia’s art, and it would be most welcome if it offered anything other than black metal for Neurosis fans. Every careful-plucked guitar arpeggio in the quieter sections resonates like an idle sound check rather than an Ennio Morricone piece. They spoil the darkwave mood of ‘Bodies as Driftwood’ with a tuneless black metal eruption just as you start to feel the thrill of the bass and drum rhythm seep into your system like a Clan of Xymox composition. ‘Unredeemable’ is, uh… unredeemable as the penultimate track because it follows most other songs as a vituperative meditation that aims to cleanse the head and inflame the heart at the same time.
Fortunately, the band’s talent for structuring an album experience carries over from the last record on Silhouettes of Disgust. That’s because the avant-garde impulses of both black and post-metal emerge in the second half of the LP and save it from the tragedy of an innocuous death. ‘Eyes to Burning Skies’ is a standout experiment with minimalist instrumentation and the splendour of a soprano voice intro from Lulu Black. The ambient soundscapes hover in the background like unrealised motions of energy waiting to be released before the band jump in with a sudden explosion of black metal ferocity at 02:40. Likewise, the dramatic staccato opening of ‘Final Vows’ dares to explore conventional metal riffing for the only time on the record with a magnificent show of force from drummer, Michael Kadnar, to bring out the best in the guitar shapes. More of these gasping moments would lift the album from satisfactory enjoyment to an enthralling one.
The integration of black metal into the post-metal landscape sounded fresh ten years ago. Now, many artists explore this territory with decreasing returns of creativity. Silhouettes of Disgust is a worthwhile piece of art, but it will lead Downfall of Gaia to consider where they go next. One feels that the band have exhausted their current sound and need a reinvention on their next effort.
JVB
Verdict


Release Date: 17/03/2023
Record Label: Metal Blade Records
Standout tracks: The Whir of Flies, Eyes to Burning Skies, Final Vows
Suggested Further Listening: Celeste – Assassine(s) (2022), Onhou – Monument (2022), Terzij De Horde – In One of These, I Am Your Enemy (2022)
