
Long Island, New York has its share of hardcore and extreme metal bands, but few that combine the two with as much expertise as Cryptodira. Their 2020 sophomore record, The Angel of History, put them on the global map and led to tours with Between the Buried and Me and Haken in 2023. Now, they have a new bassist (Vincent Romanelli) and a determination to begin a new chapter. Genesis of Error may be an EP rather than a comeback album, but it’ll stun you with its brilliance.
Naked screams of “There’s no love, there’s no love,” lead into a ferocious hardcore-infused blast of metal in opener, ‘No Monuments’. You can feel the blows to your head from the stubborn down-picked guitars. This song is heavier than an earthquake in the Japanese Archipelago until they reset at 00:40 to gentle guitars and harmonised melodies. But it’s not long until they embrace the storm once again with palm-muted riffs and eye-popping roars. The drums get into gear like a tank at full velocity, storming through a myriad of different approaches that range from sixteenth note rhythms to blast beats. Progressive metal describes this band to a tee. Their sense of dynamics shifts as easily as the seasons in northern Europe. Part two begins with a sole guitar fluttering under the direction of a plectrum working through the alt-picking techniques as the drums barge their way back in again and Scott Acquavella finds his melodic voice like a Haken release of tension. Can you gather your breath?
It’s only one minute and forty-seven seconds in length, but ‘The Same River Twice’ reminds you that metal and hardcore used to co-exist like two rival boxers fighting for the same Olympic team. Screeching feedback introduces the d-beat drama here as guitars slam on the distortion and add finger-twisting fills in between the sliding chords. Listen how the band flirt with death metal tremolos in between the muscular roars. You could even call the new modulation at 01:10 a breakdown if not for the new line of vocals. The drop-tuned riffing hangs over you like an uncontrollable impetus to use violence instead of negotiation to further your means.
In complete contrast, the title-track starts like Cynic in a Buddhist meditation. Listen to the resonance of the arpeggiated guitars as Acquavella uses his head voice to float in the wind. A second axe palm-mutes the fifth chords in the background until they erupt at the two-minute mark. How venomous are the aggressive vocals? You can feel your nose twitching in empathy. It’s easy to see why this group receive comparisons to Between the Buried and Me, but they could hold their own on a stage supporting Tool and teach them a thing or two about metal post-1993. Observe the intricacy of bass and clean guitars in the quieter moments. The former is so close to your face, you can hear the momentum of the fingers slide between the notes.
We should be counting down the days and months until the next album if this is a new chapter in the Cryptodira story. This is how you write a prog metal EP that can stand next to anything that came before it.
JVB
Verdict


Release Date: 25/07/2025
Record Label: Silent Pendulum Records
Standout track: Genesis of Error
Suggested Further Listening: Between the Buried and Me – Alaska (2005), Tool – 10,000 Days (2006), Byzantine – Harbingers (2025)
