
Cemetery Skyline is a supergroup of melodic death metal musicians who share a love of gothic rock. They came together through the songwriting partnership of keyboardist, Santeri Kallio (Amorphis), and guitarist, Markus Vanhala (Insomnium, Omnium Gatherum). This soon expanded to include Victor Brandt (Dimmu Borgir) on bass and Vesa Ranta (The Abbey) behind the drum kit, but things fell into place when the crucial role of singer landed in the lap of Dark Tranquillity legend, Mikael Stanne. You can understand why Century Media agreed to release their debut album with such an illustrious lineup, but elevating gothic rock beyond its current torpor is difficult in any circumstances.
The band are candid about their love for The Sisters of Mercy and Type O Negative, but most of Nordic Gothic is a rerun of Paradise Lost’s 1997 album, One Second. Opener, ‘Torn Away’, is keyboard-driven goth rock with an upbeat tempo and low-register vocals in the verse parts. The melodic shift to a higher voice in the chorus is as predictable as a North Korean retelling of the Second World War. You can see Andrew Eldritch appearing from behind an opening door with his large sunglasses taking up most of the frame. Fortunately, Mikael Stanne uses his experience as one of the finest singers in melodic death metal to compartmentalise his voice and emphasise the clarity of the chorus.
Essentially, this is gothic rock for a heavy metal audience in search of a palette cleanse. The new Unto Others album would be a better option. ‘In Darkness’ is the heaviest track on the record with mean chugging guitars and a keyboard choir to back it up. Stanne treats this song like a story and reaches for a soothing voice in the bridge and chorus. By contrast, the guitar takes a backseat to the glide of the keyboard presets in ‘Violent Storm’. Palm-muted power chords soon lose their potency when subordinated to the vocal lines. “There will be a raging violent storm / I don’t want to wield this power alone,” laments Stanne. The chorus is memorable here but recycling it to go an octave higher at the fourth rendition is a cliché too far.
Why does this album feel like a major label effort from 2000? It seems that these songs came into existence with no great tension or strain. Every musician knows their assigned role like a player in a football team who has a disciplined understanding of their tactical responsibilities. HIM and The Rasmus are as influential here as Type O Negative. ‘Behind the Lie’ is almost forgettable until they insert a surprise breakdown with accompanying orchestral hits. But we need a lot more than this to be rescued from the comfort of familiarity. The structures are identical in each track. Fans of Mikael Stanne will be delighted that their hero takes centre stage in ‘The Darkest Night’, but the musical timbres are too narrow to be immersive. “We’ve never had what we were prepared to lose / We never felt the need to say goodbye,” sings Stanne in ‘Never Look Back’.
Cemetery Skyline are wise enough to know that gothic rock speaks to the alienated heart of teenage girls and dark romantics. Songs like ‘When Silence Speaks’ deserve a video depicting a female protagonist who invites sympathy through her imagination of a better world where no adults exist and talking animals fulfil the role of wise guardians. But the band strangle the life out of the chorus through excess repetition. ‘The Coldest Heart’ is the only composition that achieves true greatness. Here, a spindly web of bass notes introduces the opening verse and encourages the keyboards and guitars to up their game. “This bird has flown for far too long / This bird has flown inside the prison of her mind,” intones Stanne. Listen how the mellifluous piano scales take over after the first chorus. Tori Amos would be proud of these melodies. “She felt alone in a crowded room / Where no one knew her, and no one understood.” A heroic rock solo helps them achieve a level of grandiosity lacking in other efforts.
Most of these songs could find an audience if included in a hit Netflix series that captures the attention and obsession of an intelligent teenage audience. But too much of it is predictable gothic rock with distorted guitars and ringing power chords. Closing track, ‘Alone Together’, delivers a Simple Minds ending befitting of Street Fighting Years with the added potency of maximum overdrive and the pierced heart sadness of A-Ha. But seven minutes is excessive for something that aims to be grandiloquent.
Cemetery Skyline’s influences are too obvious, and their identity suffers as a result. We know they can write songs, but too many of these feel like covers.
Verdict


Release Date: 11/10/2024
Record Label: Century Media
Standout track: In Darkness; The Coldest Heart; Behind the Lie
Suggested Further Listening: Paradise Lost – One Second (1997), Empire Drowns – Nothing (2022), HIM – Razorblade Romance (1999)
