Elderseer – Drown in the Shallowness


Surrey death-doom quartet, Elderseer, began life in 2017 and released their debut EP in 2018. Since then, their line-up underwent a couple of changes, with new guitarist, Vinny Konrad (ex-Pagan Altar/Desolate Pathway), and drummer, Darren Huckfield, joining for their 2023 debut album. At one hour and eight minutes, you’ll need the patience of a sniper to see it through to the last note. It doesn’t help that side B is their 2018 EP tagged on to the end to create the illusion of an epic double album.

There’s no doubt that Elderseer have the hallmarks of a top-class doom metal band if you analyse each track on an individual basis. The mixing and mastering are superb in the way they capture the weight of the guitars and the crystalline drum snares. Opener, ‘Gilded Shackles’, starts with harmonised guitars in mourning with the faintest of keyboards to add to the glowing pain. You might look at the 09:24 running time and wonder if you can see it through to the finish line, but Barry Copestake’s gratuitous death metal inflections will keep you on edge. Minimalist piano notes insert themselves into the mix as if responding to the droning guitars with encouragement. Like My Dying Bride, the Surrey quartet spring the sudden tempo changes on you like a triple-shot of whiskey to the head. Here, the crunch of the guitars intensifies, and the double-kick drum patterns emerge with a vicious bite. At no point do Elderseer strip everything back to the droning fifth chords and forget about your tolerance levels. Follow up, ‘Under a Dark Sky’ uses a clever high-range second guitar, like Gregor Mackintosh (Paradise Lost), to add colour to the orthodox textures of black, white and grey.

Of course, the length of this album is too long in a vexatious way, but the highpoints deserve the highest of praise. ‘This Aesthetic Life’ is as memorable as anything in the back catalogue of England’s famous Peaceville bands, with a powerful chorus and a sharp scimitar of crunchy metallic riffing. Examine the lyrics and you’ll find a poignant analysis of the social Darwinian reality at the heart of our so-called meritocratic system: “Work yourself to the bone/ Worship the machine or die alone/ Don’t defy, get in line/ On the outside you’ll appear just fine.” ‘She is the Ocean’ wastes no time in reaching for the venomous hiss of classic death-doom when your mind threatens to wander. The dropout to clean guitars and ambient pedal loops at the two-minute mark will leave you unprepared for the thudding bass and vicious guitar rhythms that follow. It might be eight minutes in length, but not one of them goes to waste.

The problem with this album is the illusion that it’s an epic record. As stated at the beginning, this is a thirty-six-minute LP with the group’s 2018 EP added on for no apparent reason. These last four songs appear to be untouched since their original recordings. You can tell the personnel were different on side B in the way they experiment with faster tempos. ‘The Struggle is Ethereal’ will remind you of the epic moments of vintage Paradise Lost from the Icon era but with a dash of modern Carcass. Maybe including just one of these tracks would have been the right thing to do rather than providing us with a bloated listening experience. Both records ought to be enjoyed in separate listening sessions as two different releases.

Elderseer show their capabilities on their debut album, but they need to be conscious of the listener in the process. The average song length is eight minutes. Do we need eight of them to recognise their talent? You should know the answer to that.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 03/02/2023

Record Label: Meuse Music Records

Standout tracks: Gilded Shackles, This Aesthetic Life, She is the Ocean

Suggested Further Listening: Paradise Lost – Medusa (2017), My Dying Bride – The Ghost of Orion (2020), Onhou – Monument (2022)