
As far as cult bands go, Green Carnation have more pedigree than most. Founded by ex-Emperor bassist, Tschort, in 1990, and featuring members of avant garde metal legends, In The Woods…, they have a string of admirers who look forward to each release with the same relish as snow-deprived Eskimos.
For a band that created a 60-minute single track of experimental metal with 2001’s, Light of Day, Day of Darkness, you never know what to expect from Green Carnation. Their 2004 offering, The Quiet Offspring, is straight-up hard rock yet their debut is a gothic metal feast and their roots are death metal. On this release we get five tracks of prog metal in the same mould as Psychotic Waltz and Dream Theater, but with a sound that is still recognisable as their own.
Unlike most prog bands, Green Carnation build their sound around the powerful vocals of Kjetil Nordhus and flesh out the more virtuoso compositions as an offshoot of his voice. This is welcome and shows they’re not afraid to demonstrate their song-writing credentials as the standard for which to judge their art. Opener, ‘Leaves of Yesteryear’, is a fine start with a nod to Paradise Lost’s classic Icon album and a willingness to explore Pink Floyd territory for a more pensive soundscape. Nordhus’ melodic delivery in the chorus introduces a sombre element finessed by analogue keyboards that give it a pyrrhic victory over the demons of loneliness. Shades of Opeth and Katatonia emerge throughout these eight minutes of melancholy metal and it’s a mood that runs through the rest of the album. The recurring palm-muted riff of ‘Sentinels’ is worthy of Nevermore playing to a stadium of old school metalheads, while the heroic chorus of ‘Hounds’ battles with great fortitude and delivers us from the sorrowful guitar picking at the beginning. One listen to the latter will have you singing along with a closed fist in the air and a desire to conquer your anxieties. Dream Theater’s Images and Words is an obvious reference point for this invigorating piece of prog metal mastery.
The only weakness of this triumphant comeback is the fifteen-minute anchor of the record, ‘My Dark Reflections of Life and Death’. This track never reaches the epic dimension it deserves, with the listener wondering after five minutes if a pattern or direction will emerge. Instead, it plods along at a goth metal pace and fails to deliver the climax of metallic flourishes we expect from a composition of this length. Whether we need fifteen minutes of this is debatable even if the bass and acoustic guitar soloing hit the spot at the nine-minute mark.
Fourteen years is a long time to wait for a new release, but Leaves of Yesteryear is a strong comeback and has the making of a new chapter in the band’s career. Including a cover of Black Sabbath’s ‘Solitude’ to end the record is a brave move but one that deserves praise. Imagine Moby interpreting the original and covering it with piano splashes for Nordhus to sing over. It’s a surprising success and worthy of Birmingham’s finest.
Our only hope is the next album arrives in less than a decade.
JVB
Verdict

Release Date: 08/05/2020
Record Label: Season of Mist
Standout tracks: Leaves of Yesteryear, Sentinels, Hounds
Suggested Further Listening: Paradise Lost – Icon (1993), Dream Theater – Images and Words (1992), Psychotic Waltz – The God-Shaped Void (2020)
