
It’s rare you find a band that start off as a death-thrash outfit before evolving into a symphonic heavy metal tour de force. Perhaps the most famous example is the transformation of Carcass from goregrind pioneers to godfathers of melodic death metal. But Los Angeles sextet, Our Dying World, take things to a new level with their sophomore effort. Is this even the same band that produced 2019’s Expedition LP?
You know from the first twenty seconds of intro piece, ‘Ars Moriendi’, that Our Dying World are out to redefine their approach to metal. The dramatic string ensemble rotations and murderous horn section will stretch your eyelids with the macabre delight of a deranged composer. No wonder this band made it to the national finals of the Wacken Metal Battle USA. Keyboardist, Graham Southern, is probably the most important member of the new sound. Listen how he weaves in and out of the Dorian scale uplift of ‘Everything We Know is Gone’ as the guitarists explore a darker harmonic minor passage of thrash metal rhythms. Those who feared that vocalist, David Ainsworth, might abandon the muscular death metal growls have nothing to worry about here. Yet the inclusion of an extravagant keyboard solo to rival the fret-shredding guitar work is something you never thought possible after listening to this band’s debut album. ‘Under the Hunter’s Blade’ might even qualify as folk metal with its use of Celtic pentatonic scales and dangerous flirtation with the ‘pirate metal’ sound that’s so unlistenable. A nod to Septicflesh at the end cannot save this one from the skip button.
Our Dying World deserve full marks for imagination and enthusiasm, but their musical execution sometimes trails the boldness of their ideas. ‘Survivor’ will appeal to the Therion fanbase with its epic heavy metal flavour and swirling symphonics, but there is no justification for stretching it beyond seven minutes. ‘Path of the Nomad’ is a stubborn attempt to merge Nightwish with Lamb of God, but it pleases neither side with its overemphasis on the harsh vocals to see it through to the end. We’re heading for mediocrity at the three-quarter mark. How can you lose the interest of your listener with such exquisite musicianship and creative risk-taking? The answer is not obvious, but it dawns on you. This is an LA band hoping to sound like a Swedish or Finnish melodic death metal. It doesn’t sit right.
Fortunately, the vitality of the band’s influences ensures a strong ending to Hymns of Blinding Darkness. Six people in the group means six potential forces pulling away from the core with their own musical agendas. ‘Diary of a War Dog’ is a magnificent piece of head-swinging thrash that would light up the latest Darkane record. Here, the effulgent orchestrations remain in the background while the guitars command your attention. You can hear At the Gates, but you can also detect the colourful springs of Wilderun in the quieter dynamics. Closing track, ‘Veil of the Reaper’ is almost as thrilling with its accelerated stomp reminding you of Chimaira when they switched from nu metal to thrash in the early 2000s. There’s a vintage Megadeth flair to the ostentatious guitar leads and a Dream Theater extravaganza in the keyboard heroics. They almost spoil it with the ultimate power metal cliché by going up an octave for the chorus repeat, but the chugging breakdown riff at the end will put a gurn back on your face.
Our Dying World have an abundance of ideas but too few moments when they realise their full potential. Hymns of Blinding Darkness is a welcome evolution in the band’s growth, but they’d do well to recalibrate their sound back to a more uncompromising extreme metal crunch without abandoning their newfound glory. You wouldn’t best against them achieving this aim on their next LP.
JVB
Verdict

Release Date: 24/06/2022
Record Label: Self Released
Standout tracks: Everything We Know is Gone, Diary of a War Dog, Veil of the Reaper
Suggested Further Listening: Naraka – In Tenebris (2021), Age of Athena – Gate to Oblivion (2021), Aephanemer – A Dream of Wilderness (2021)
